Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Al Mofada 1994 | Patients were enrolled immediately after birth. The volume of RBC transfusions was reported as mL/week over the study period. We could not use this information in our outcome of total volume (mL/kg) of blood transfused per infant. |
Amin 2002 | This study was not a randomised controlled trial. |
Basiri 2015 | Infants were > 6 days old. Will be included in the 'Late EPO' review. |
Bierer 2006 | One of the authors of this study, Dr. R.K. Ohls, informed us that this study reported on a subgroup of Ohls 2001A. All outcomes of Bierer 2006 were included in the 2004 follow‐up publication of Ohls 2001A. |
Brown 1999 | This study compared 2 different dosing regimens for the same total weekly dose of EPO. The trial included no control or placebo group. |
Costa 2013 | This study assessed the effectiveness of IV vs SC administration of EPO and included no non‐treated group. |
Fearing 2002 | This study did not reveal the number of infants allocated to treatment and control groups, nor the age at which the infants entered into the study. |
Haiden 2006a | This study reported the same findings as Haiden 2005. |
Haiden 2006b | Both study groups received erythropoietin. |
Juul 2008 | This was not a randomised controlled trial. |
Klipp 2007 | This was a randomised controlled trial, but results showed no clinical outcomes of interest for this review. |
Krallis 1999 | No outcomes of interest for this review were reported. |
López‐Catzín 2015 | Upon consultation with one of the trial authors (Bolado‐Garcia PB), it was clarified that this was not a randomised controlled trial. |
Maggio 2007 | This randomised controlled trial compared the effectiveness of EPO administered by continuous intravenous vs subcutaneous route. |
Maier 1998 | This randomised controlled trial compared 2 doses of EPO: 750 IU/kg/week vs 1500 IU/kg/week without a non‐treated control group. |
Ohls 1996 | This study compared different routes of administration (SC EPO vs EPO added to the total parenteral nutrition fluid). This study included no untreated control group. |
Saeidi 2012 | This was a randomised controlled trial in which one group received oral EPO, and the other group SC EPO. The trial included no untreated control group. |
Soubasi 2005 | 128 infants were randomised early (first week of life) to EPO group (n = 66) or control group (n = 62). The dose of EPO is not stated in the abstract. Infants randomised to EPO received significantly fewer transfusions and had less IVH. |
Soubasi 2009 | Not a randomised controlled trial (20 study participants and 20 concurrent controls). |
Turker 2005 | This study was labelled by trial authors as a quasi‐randomised (assignment on an alternating basis) trial. Study authors reported on uneven numbers in the 2 groups (42 infants in the EPO group and 51 in the control group). On request, the principal author provided the following information. "In the study period 112 premature infants < 1500 grams were followed in the NICU. Informed consents were obtained from the parents of 97 babies, but only 93 babies completed the study because 3 patients were lost to follow‐up after discharge and one baby died of bronchopulmonary dysplasia before completing the 12 week monitoring period. These 4 babies were omitted from the study group (r‐Hu EPO+enteral iron). These infants are included in the result section. At the end of the study r‐Hu EPO was not available, and 2 more patients had only iron supplementation. Then the study was closed and these 2 babies were also added to the control group". 97 participants (48 in EPO group; 3 lost‐to follow‐up; 1 death; ‐2 rHuEPO unavailable; 49 controls; +2) Based on this information, we excluded the study, as it was not a quasi‐randomised trial. |
Vázquez López 2011 | This randomised controlled trial compared 2 different dosing schedules of EPO. Group 1 (60 infants; mean postnatal age at entry 6 ± 3.1 days) received SC EPO at 250 units per kg per dose, 3 times weekly for 6 weeks. Group 2 (59 infants; mean postnatal age at entry 7 ± 3.9 days) received SC EPO at 750 units per kg per dose once weekly for 6 weeks. No untreated group was included. |
Zhu 2009 | Trial population consisted of infants > 37 weeks' PMA. |
EPO: erythropoietin. IV: intravenous. IVH: intraventricular haemorrhage. RBC: red blood cell. SC: subcutaneous.