Skip to main content
. 2017 Dec 1;2017(12):CD004956. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004956.pub3

1. Principal study characteristics.

Study ID Intervention Comparator Alkaline phosphatase Follow‐up N Age Male Symptomatic Previously treated
Altman 1973 Etidronate Placebo Yes 6 m 50 67 y 60% NA NA
Canfield 1977 Etidronate Placebo Yes 6 m 48 NA 58% NA NA
Ralston 1987 Etidronate Placebo No 3 m 32 NA NA 100% 38%
Fraser 1997 Tiludronate Placebo Yes 6 m
 (18 m) 112 70 y 54% 63% NA
McClung 1995 Tiludronate Placebo Yes 6 m 139 70 y 54% NA NA
Reginster 1992 Tiludronate Placebo Yes 6 m 149 69 y 54% NA 82%
O'Doherty 1992 Alendronate Placebo Yes 6 m 15 67 y 60% 87% 66%
Reid 1996 Alendronate Placebo Yes 6 m 55 70 y 56% NA 35%
Buckler 1999 Zoledronate Placebo Yes 3 m 176 71 y 61% NA NA
Reid 2004 Ibandronate Placebo Yes 6 m
 (12 m) 25 73 y 74% NA 64%
Roux 1995 Tiludronate Etidronate Yes 6m 234 69y 59% 74% 71%
Siris 1996 Alendronate Etidronate Yes 6m 89 69y 67% NA 25%
Miller 1999 Risedronate Etidronate Yes 12 m
 (18 m) 123 66 y 69% 91% 72%
Walsh 2004 Alendronate Pamidronate Yes 12 m
 (24 m) 72 70 y 58% 94% 39%
Barreira 2009 Olpadronate Pamidronate Yes 6 m 27 NA NA NA NA
Merlotti 2007 Zoledronate Pamidronate Yes 6 m 90 70 y 69% 99% 67%
Reid 2005 Zoledronate Risedronate Yes 6 m
 (6.5 y) 357 70 y 68% NA 54%
O'Donoghue 1987 Etidronate +
calcitonin
Etidronate Yes 12 m 44 NA NA 100% 10%
Langston 2010 Intensive Symptomatic No 3 y 1331 74 y 51% 69% NA
Tan 2017 Intensive Symptomatic No 3 y 502 76 y 55% 63% 70%

Alkaline phosphatase: Serum total alkaline phosphatase above the upper limit of normal as an inclusion criterion. Follow‐up: Extended follow‐up periods are shown in parentheses. N: Number of randomised participants. NA: Not available. SC: Sample size calculated before study.