Skip to main content
. 2016 Apr 4;2016(4):CD011586. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD011586.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Anzai 1989 Wrong population: fewer than 75% patients with PU
Baker 1981 Not a randomised controlled trial
Bale 2004 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Bazzigaluppi 1991 Not a randomised controlled trial
Becker 1984 Not a randomised controlled trial
Beele 2010 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Boykin 1989 Not a randomised controlled trial
Chirwa 2010 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Colombo 1993 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
de Laat 2011 Wrong intervention
Della Marchina 1997 Not a randomised controlled trial
Gerding 1992 Wrong population: mixed stage 1 and higher PU stage 2+ under 75%.
Gorse 1987 Use of antiseptic/antibiotic not the only difference between intervention arms
Hartman 2002 Not a randomised controlled trial
Helaly 1988 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Ishibashi 1996 Wrong population: fewer than 75% patients with PU
Itani 2010 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Kim 1996 Wrong population: mixed stage 1 and higher PU stage 2+ under 75%.
Konychev 2013 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Kuroyanagi 1995 Not a randomised controlled trial
Lazareth 2012 Wrong population, not PU
Lee 2014 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
LeVasseur 1991 Wrong intervention
Meaume 2005 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Motta 2004 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Munter 2006 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Parish 1984a Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Parish 1984b Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Rhodes 2001 Quasi‐randomised
Robson 1999 Wrong intervention
Romanelli 2008 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Saha 2012 Quasi‐randomised
Saydak 1990 Not a randomised controlled trial
Serra 2005 Not a randomised controlled trial
Shrivastava 2011 Wrong comparator
Sibbald 2011 Wrong population: not PU
Stevens 2002 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Thomas 1998 Wrong intervention
Trial 2010 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
van der Cammen 1987 Wrong population: patients at risk of pressure sores
Wang 2014 Wrong intervention
Weheida 1991 Wrong population: Stage 1 pressure ulcers
Worsley 1991 Wrong population: minority of patients with PU
Yastrub 2005 No relevant outcomes
Yura 1984 Wrong population: fewer than 75% patients with PU
Zeron 2007 Wrong intervention