TABLE 1.
State* | Year Notified† |
Health Care Setting |
No. Persons Notified‡, n |
Unsafe Injection Practices§ |
Medication(s) Involved | Notified by Whom |
References |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Evidence of bloodborne pathogen transmission at the time notification was initiated∥ | |||||||
Patient-to-patient transmission | |||||||
New York | 2001 | Endoscopy clinic | 2009 | Suspected syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Unspecified anesthesia medications | Health department | Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,7 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, unpublished data |
New York | 2002 | Physician office | 1042 | Mishandling of medication vials and injection equipment, medication preparation in contaminated environment | Atropine, dexamethasone, and vitamin B12 | Health department | Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,7 Samandari et al11 |
Oklahoma | 2002 | Pain management clinic affiliated with a hospital | 908 | Overt syringe reuse from one patient to another | Midazolam, fentanyl, and propofol | Affiliated hospital | Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,7 Comstock et al12 |
Nebraska | 2002 | Hematology/oncology clinic | 613 | Syringe reuse contaminating saline bags | Saline flush | Health department | Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,7 Macedo de Oliveria et al13 |
New York | 2003 | Endoscopy clinic | 1199 | Suspected needle or syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Unspecified anesthesia medications | Health department | Marx et al,14 New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, unpublished data |
California | 2003 | Pain management clinic | 52 | Suspected syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Lidocaine | Health department | San Diego County Department of Health and Human Services, unpublished data |
Florida | 2005 | Alternative medicine clinic | 253 | Mishandling of medication vials, failure to prepare and store intravenous infusions under aseptic conditions | Unspecified chelating agent | Health department | Sanderson et al15 |
New York | 2007¶ | Pain management clinic, physician office (orthopedic) | 9000 | Syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Bupivacaine, ketorolac, triamcinolone, iohexol (contrast) | Health department | New York State Department of Health, unpublished data |
New York | 2007 | Multiple endoscopy and ambulatory surgical centers | 4490 | Suspected syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Propofol | Health department | Gutelius et al16 |
New York | 2008 | Endoscopy clinic | 259 | Suspected mishandling of single-dose vials for multiple patients | Propofol | Health department | New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, unpublished data |
Nevada | 2008 | Ambulatory surgical centers (single-purpose endoscopy clinics) | 63,000 | Syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Propofol | Health department | Fischer et al,17 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention,18 Southern Nevada Health District19 |
North Carolina | 2008 | Cardiology clinic | 1205 | Syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Saline flush | Health department | Moore et al20 |
New Jersey | 2009 | Hematology/oncology clinic | 4600 | Mishandling of medication vials, medication preparation in contaminated environment, common-use saline bag for multiple patients | Saline flush, possibly unspecified chemotherapy agents | Health department | Greeley et al21 |
Florida | 2009 | Alternative medicine clinic | 163 | Syringe reuse contaminating medication vials, mishandling of medication preparation | Various infusion therapies, including EDTA and vitamin C | Clinic, health department | Florida Department of Health, unpublished data |
New York | 2009 | Endoscopy clinic | 3287 | Suspected syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Propofol | Health department | New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, unpublished data |
New Jersey | 2010 | Hospital | 80 | Suspected mishandling of single-dose vials for multiple patients | Propofol | Hospital | New Jersey Department of Health and Senior Services, unpublished data |
New Jersey | 2010 | Long-term care facility | 182 | Suspected mishandling of insulin pens for multiple patients, mishandling of medication preparation | Insulin, other unspecified medications | Long-term care facility, health department | New Jersey Department of Health and Senior Services, unpublished data |
California | 2011 | Pain management clinic | 2293 | Syringe reuse contaminating medication vials, mishandling of medication preparation | Lidocaine, iohexol (contrast), sodium bicarbonate | Health department | Los Angeles County Department of Public Health22 |
New York | 2011 | Pain management clinic | 466 | Suspected syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Propofol, midazolam, lidocaine | Health department | New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene, unpublished data |
Provider-to-patient transmission | |||||||
Texas, Virginia, District of Columbia | 2004 | Hospitals | 543 | Contamination of vials/syringes, narcotics diversion by provider | Fentanyl | Hospitals | Nahill,23 CDC, unpublished data |
Colorado, New York | 2009 | Hospitals, ambulatory surgical center | 8690 | Syringe reuse, narcotics diversion by provider | Fentanyl | Hospitals and ambulatory surgical center | Denver Channel,24 Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment25 |
Florida | 2010 | Multispecialty clinic affiliated with a hospital | 3929 | Syringe reuse, narcotics diversion by provider | Fentanyl | Hospital | Hellinger et al26 |
Absence of known bloodborne pathogen transmission at the time notification was initiated | |||||||
Rhode Island | 2005 | Physician office | 669 | Overt syringe reuse from one patient to another | Vitamin B12 | Health department | Rhode Island Department of Health, unpublished data |
Michigan | 2007 | Physician office (dermatology) | 13,500 | Suspected overt syringe reuse and reuse of surgical instruments from one patient to another | Unspecified | Health department | Kent County Health Department27 |
New York | 2008 | Physician office (obstetrics/gynecology) | 36 | Overt syringe reuse from one patient to another | Influenza vaccine | Physician office | New York State Department of Health28 |
New York | 2008 | Hospital | 185 | Suspected overt reuse of insulin pen from one patient to another | Insulin | Hospital | NewsInferno29 |
Texas | 2009 | Hospital | 2114 | Overt reuse of insulin pen from one patient to another | Insulin | Hospital | William Beaumont Army Medical Center30 |
West Virginia# | 2009 | Pain management clinic | 110 | Syringe reuse contaminating medication vials | Various medication including triamcinolone and lidocaine, iopamidol (contrast) | Health department | Radcliffe et al31 |
Florida | 2009 | Hospital | 1851 | Overt reuse of saline bag and intravenous tubing from one patient to another | Saline | Hospital | Broward General Medical Center32 |
New York | 2010 | Physician office | 25 | Suspected overt syringe reuse from one patient to another | Influenza vaccine | Physician office | New York State Department of Health, unpublished data |
Pennsylvania | 2010 | Outpatient clinic affiliated with a hospital | 250 | Overt syringe reuse from one patient to another | Botulinum toxin | Affiliated hospital | Fabregas33 |
Colorado | 2011 | Outpatient clinic | 171 | Overt syringe reuse from one patient to another | Influenza vaccine | Clinic | Dickinson,34 Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, unpublished data |
Mississippi# | 2011 | Oncology clinic | 623 | Overt syringe reuse from one patient to another, and syringe reuse over multiple days contaminating saline bags and heparin bags | Heparin and saline flushes | Health department | Mississippi State Department of Health, unpublished data |
Wisconsin | 2011 | Primary care clinic | 2345 | Overt reuse of insulin demonstration pen from one patient to another | Saline or possibly nonsterile water | Clinic | Seely,35 Wisconsin Division of Public Health, unpublished data |
Wisconsin | 2011 | Hospital | 56 | Overt reuse of insulin demonstration pen from one patient to another | Saline or possibly nonsterile water | Hospital | Wisconsin Division of Public Health, unpublished data |
This indicates only the states where facilities associated with patient notifications were located and does not take into account additional states where affected patients might have been residing at the time of potential exposure or notification.
For notification events that had multiple rounds of notifications, this indicates the year of first round of notifications.
Represents the estimated minimum number of patients notified.
Indicates documented lapses (based on direct observations or interviews with the implicated provider) unless otherwise specified.
These notification events took place in the context of public health investigations in which health care was recognized as the source of hepatitis B or C virus transmission.
Preliminary investigation involved initial notification of 98 patients in 2005, but formal notification activities were not conducted until 2007.
Patient notifications prompted by breaches identified in the context of a bacterial outbreak: Staphylococcus aureus infections following epidural injections in West Virginia, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Klebsiella pneumoniae infections in Mississippi.
CDC indicates Centers for Disease Control and Prevention; EDTA, ethylenediamine tetraacetic acid.