Skip to main content
. 2017 Nov 14;2017(11):CD009740. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009740.pub3

1. Content of the interventions.

Study name Device Commercial Names Device Category Safety Device type passive/
active
For sale?
Asai 1999 active Insyte AutoGuard intravenous cannula Safe IV system (insertion) button for actively retracting the needle active Yes
Asai 2002 active Insyte Autoguard intravenous cannula Safe IV system (insertion) button for actively retracting the needle active Yes
Asai 2002 passive Protective Acuvance Safe IV system (insertion) automated retraction of needle passive Yes
Azar‐Cavanagh 2007 Unnamed intravenous catheter stylet Safe IV system (insertion) retractable protection shield active? ?
Baskin 2014 BD Eclipse injector 3‐mL, BD preset syringe with BD Luer‐Lok tip 25G×1 Blood collection cannula protection shield is activated with one hand after puncture and clicks irreversibly over the cannula active Yes
Chambers 2015 hospitals not reported Multiple safe devices safety engineered needles and needleless devices passive or semi‐automatic ?
Chambers 2015 long‐term nursing care nor reported Multiple safe devices safety engineered needles and needleless devices passive or semi‐automatic ?
Cote 2003 Angiocath Autoguard IV catheters Safe IV system (insertion) button for actively retracting the needle active Yes
Edmond 1988 Winfield sharpsguard Sharps container bedside sharps container n.a. No
Gaballah 2010 Unnamed safety dental syringes Injection system does not require re‐sheating or removal of the needle from its syringe passive? ?
Goldwater 1989 Needle guard Biosafe New Zealand Blood collection shield on cap prevents injury while recapping n.a. No
Goris 2015 Unnamed safety engineered passive retractable syringes Injection system automatically and instantly retracts the needle from the patient into the barrel of the syringe passive ?
Grimmond 2010 Daniels sharpsmart Sharps container bedside sharps container n.a. Yes
L'Ecuyer 1996 2wva 2‐way valve Safsite Braun medical Safe IV system (insertion and needleless) two valve system with plastic sharp that remains in the device passive Yes
L'Ecuyer 1996 mbc Lifeshield metal blunt cannula Safe IV system (needleless iv system) metal blunt cannula passive Yes
L'Ecuyer 1996 pbc Interlink PBC plastic cannula Safe IV system (insertion and needleless) plastic sharp covered by blunt plastic cannula passive Yes
Mendelson 1998 1‐valve Safsite Braun medical Safe IV system (needleless) valve of IV system incompatible with needle passive Yes
Phillips 2013 safety engineered sharps Multiple safe devices not explained ? ?
Prunet 2008 active Insyte Autoguard intravenous cannula Safe IV system (insertion) button for actively retracting the needle active Yes
Prunet 2008 passive Introcan Safety IV system (Braun) Safe IV system (insertion) automatic shield on needle tip at withdrawing passive Yes
Reddy 2001 'safety syringes and needleless IV' Multiple safe devices not explained ? ?
Richard 2001 'sharps containers' Sharps container first in treatment rooms later bedside placements ? ?
Rogues 2004 SafetyLock BD, resheathable winged steel needle Blood collection after pushing (two handed) needle retracts into sheath active Yes
Seiberlich 2016 ViaValve safety I.V. catheter Safe IV system
(insertion)
contains a valve that is designed to restrict blood flow back out of the catheter hub upon initial venipuncture active Yes
Sossai 2010 Introcan safety IV system (Braun) Safe IV system (insertion) automatic shield on needle tip at withdrawing passive Yes
Valls 2007 Eclipse BD; Saf‐T‐ E‐Z Set, BD; Surshield, Terumo; Preserts BD; Provent plus, Smiths; Genie BD; Surgilance Terumo; Blunt administration needles BD Multiple systems n.a. active and passive Yes
van der Molen 2011 Eclipse BD Injection system after injection needle covered with shield active Yes
Whitby 2008 VanishPoint; VanishPoint blood tube holders; BD Safety‐Lok; SmartSite needle‐free system; Smartsite Plus Multiple systems retractable syringes, needle‐free IV systems and safety winged butterfly needles. passive Yes
Zakrzweska 2001 Safety Plus Septodont (Dental injections) Injection system Protective sheaths can be temporarily or definitely protect the needle active Yes