Skip to main content
. 2018 Jan 29;2018(1):CD009728. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009728.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Bartholomew 2011 Study did not meet intervention criteria: Physical activity intervention was a short bout, 3 days of physically active lessons, which is too short to be considered as a lifestyle intervention for treatment of overweight and obesity
Chaya 2012 Study did not meet the control group criteria: The study used a physical activity control arm
Crova 2014 Study did not aim to prevent obesity (this was confirmed by the study authors on correspondence)
Delgado‐Rico 2012b Study did not meet study design criteria: It followed a non‐randomised, uncontrolled, pre/postintervention design
Donnelly 2009 Study did not report data for children with obesity or overweight and we were not able to obtain the data from the authors
Donnelly 2013 Study did not report data for children with obesity or overweight and we were not able to obtain the data from the authors
Epstein 2000 Study did not meet control group criteria: All experimental groups received family‐based weight management treatment
Gee 2014 Study obtained cognitive outcomes using self‐ or parent‐reported questionnaire
Gentile 2009 Study did not report data for children with obesity or overweight and we were not able to obtain the data from the authors
Goldfield 2012 Study obtained academic outcomes by self‐reported questionnaire
Grieco 2009 Study did not meet study design and intervention criteria: It followed a non‐randomised, uncontrolled, pre/postintervention design and delivered an acute bout intervention
Gunnarsdottir 2012b Study did not meet study design criteria: It followed a non‐randomised, uncontrolled, pre/postintervention design
Halberstadt 2017 Study did not meet design criteria: It was a single group before‐after trial
Hill 2011 Study measured outcome during the intervention rather than at baseline and at end of intervention
Hillman 2014 Study did not report data for children with obesity or overweight and we were not able to obtain the data from the authors
Hollar 2010 Study did not meet design criteria: It followed a non‐randomised cluster controlled design
Hutson 2008 Unclear whether study included children with obesity or overweight. Outcome data were not separately reported. Author's contact details not obtainable
Leidy 2013 Study measured school achievement and unrelated cognitive domains (appetite control and satiety regulation) using test tools not specified as eligible in this review (functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) brain activation responses)
Milosis 2007 Primary outcome measure of school achievement was assessed through self‐reported grades
Murray 2008 Study did not report data for children with obesity or overweight and we were not able to obtain the data from the authors
Muzaffar 2014 Study obtained cognitive outcomes using self‐ and parent‐reported questionnaire
Naar‐King 2016 Study obtained cognitive outcomes using self‐ or parent‐reported questionnaire
Pentz 2011 Study obtained cognitive outcomes using self‐ or parent‐reported questionnaire
Pesce 2016b Study did not aim to prevent or treat obesity (this was confirmed by the study authors on correspondence)
Puder 2011 Study did not report data for children with obesity or overweight and we were not able to obtain the data from the authors
Reed 2010 Study did not report data for children with obesity or overweight and we were not able to obtain the data from the authors
Reed 2012 Study did not meet study design criteria: It followed a non‐randomised, pre/postintervention design
Robinson 2010 Primary outcome measure of school achievement was assessed through self‐reported grades
Salmoirago‐Blotcher 2015 Study obtained cognitive outcomes using self‐ or parent‐reported questionnaire
Smith 2015 Study obtained cognitive outcomes using self‐ or parent‐reported questionnaire
Tomporowski 2008 Study did not meet intervention criteria: Physical activity intervention was a short bout, one‐off session of 23 minutes of treadmill walking, which is not considered a lifestyle intervention for treatment of overweight and obesity
Vanhelst 2012 Study did not meet study design criteria: It followed a non‐randomised, uncontrolled, pre/postintervention design
Verbeken 2013 Study did not meet control group and lifestyle intervention criteria: Control group received same lifestyle intervention as intervention group. Intervention group played a computer game to train executive function, which was not considered an adequate lifestyle intervention according to our definition
Vos 2011 Study did not meet the outcome criteria: Cognitive function was assessed as self‐perceived ability
Wong 2016 Study obtained academic outcomes from self‐report