4. Efficacy and effectiveness data from intra‐epidemic and non‐typical studies.
Study reference | Exclusion reason | RCT/cohort | Vaccine | Age group | Outcome | n treatment | N treatment | n control | N control |
Nicholls 2004 | Cohort from community not representative of local population | Cohort | Inactive, trivalent | 0 to 2 years | ILI | 11 | 18 | 3 | 5 |
Nicholls 2004 | Cohort from community not representative of local population | Cohort | Inactive, trivalent | 3 to 4 years | ILI | 10 | 16 | 0 | 0 |
Nicholls 2004 | Cohort from community not representative of local population | Cohort | Inactive, trivalent | 5 to 14 years | ILI | 39 | 91 | 0 | 3 |
Slepushkin 1974 | Intra‐epidemic study of orally administered vaccine as emergency prophylaxis | RCT | Live (oral) H2N2+B | 1 to 3 years | Influenza or ARI >= 10 days after vaccination | 187 | 508 | 271 | 492 |
Ritzwoller 2005 | Intra‐epidemic study | Cohort | Inactive, trivalent | 6 to 23 months | ILI | 65 | 1129 | 124 | 1615 |
Aksenov 1971 | Intra‐epidemic study | Cohort | Live, H2N2+B, 3 doses 5 days apart | 4 to 7 years | Morbidity due to influenza and ARI | 107 | 760 | 164 | 594 |
Aksenov 1971 | Intra‐epidemic study | Cohort | Live, H2N2+B, 3 doses 8 to 10 days apart | 4 to 7 years | Morbidity due to influenza and ARI | 81 | 728 | 193 | 674 |
Aksenov 1971 | Intra‐epidemic study | Cohort | Live, H2N2+B, 3 doses 5 days apart | 7 to 15 years | Morbidity due to influenza and ARI | 143 | 1358 | 114 | 776 |
Cowling 2012 | Intra‐epidemic study | RCT | TIV or saline placebo during the 2009–10 pandemic | 6 to 17 years | Morbidity due to influenza | Unclear | 479 | Unclear | 317 |
ARI: acute respiratory infection ILI: influenza‐like illness RCT: randomised controlled trial TIV: trivalent influenza vaccine