Skip to main content
. 2018 Feb 1;2018(2):CD004879. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD004879.pub5

4. Efficacy and effectiveness data from intra‐epidemic and non‐typical studies.

Study reference Exclusion reason RCT/cohort Vaccine Age group Outcome n treatment N treatment n control N control
Nicholls 2004 Cohort from community not representative of local population Cohort Inactive, trivalent 0 to 2 years ILI 11 18 3 5
Nicholls 2004 Cohort from community not representative of local population Cohort Inactive, trivalent 3 to 4 years ILI 10 16 0 0
Nicholls 2004 Cohort from community not representative of local population Cohort Inactive, trivalent 5 to 14 years ILI 39 91 0 3
                   
Slepushkin 1974 Intra‐epidemic study of orally administered vaccine as emergency prophylaxis RCT Live (oral) H2N2+B 1 to 3 years Influenza or ARI >= 10 days after vaccination 187 508 271 492
                   
Ritzwoller 2005 Intra‐epidemic study Cohort Inactive, trivalent 6 to 23 months ILI 65 1129 124 1615
                   
Aksenov 1971 Intra‐epidemic study Cohort Live, H2N2+B, 3 doses 5 days apart 4 to 7 years Morbidity due to influenza and ARI 107 760 164 594
Aksenov 1971 Intra‐epidemic study Cohort Live, H2N2+B, 3 doses 8 to 10 days apart 4 to 7 years Morbidity due to influenza and ARI 81 728 193 674
Aksenov 1971 Intra‐epidemic study Cohort Live, H2N2+B, 3 doses 5 days apart 7 to 15 years Morbidity due to influenza and ARI 143 1358 114 776
                   
Cowling 2012 Intra‐epidemic study RCT TIV or saline placebo during the 2009–10 pandemic 6 to 17 years Morbidity due to influenza Unclear 479 Unclear 317

ARI: acute respiratory infection
 ILI: influenza‐like illness
 RCT: randomised controlled trial
 TIV: trivalent influenza vaccine