Skip to main content
. 2016 Jan 5;2016(1):CD001800. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001800.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Agren 1989 Improper method of randomisation (based on date of birth).
Andersson 2010 Comparator received exercise.
Aronov 2006 No useful outcome data reported.
Asbury 2012 Follow up only 16 weeks.
Astengo 2010 No outcomes of interest reported.
Ballantyne 1982 No useful outcome data reported
Belardinelli 2007 Abstract only with incomplete reporting of study characteristics and outcome data. Full trial report not published.
Bilinska 2010 Follow up only 6 weeks.
Bilinska 2013 Follow up only 6 weeks.
Björntorp 1972 Not a randomised study ‐ participants divided alternately after admission.
Blumenthal 1997 Control group was not randomised, but selected on geographical basis.
Bourke 2010 Trial terminated early due to poor recruitment.
Bubnova 2014 No outcomes of interest reported.
Busch 2012 Comparator received exercise.
Butler 2009 Participants had already received rehabilitation.
Bär 1992 Method of randomisation was inadequate; of a study population of 265 across 5 centres only one centre randomised their patients, leaving a control group of 50 and an intervention group of 215.
Carlsson 1997 No useful outcome data reported.
Chang 2010 No outcomes of interest reported.
Chatian 2014 No outcomes of interest reported and follow up only 3 months.
Chow 2012 Intervention does not contain exercise.
Edstrom‐Pluss 2009 Comparator received exercise.
Espinosa 2004 Not an RCT.
Gao 2007 No useful outcome data reported. Duration of follow‐up not reported.
Ghashghaei 2012 Not an RCT.
Giallauria 2009 No outcomes of interest.
Giallauria 2012 No outcomes of interest.
Giallauria 2013 No outcomes of interest.
Giannuzzi 2008 All patients (treatment and control) participated in 3 to 6 week cardiac rehabilitation programme (including supervised exercise sessions) prior to randomisation. Control group was not "usual care".
Gielen 2003 No useful outcome data reported.
Ha 2011 Not an RCT.
Haddadzadeh 2011 Follow up only 12 weeks.
Hansen 2009 Not an RCT.
Hansen 2010 Not an RCT.
Hanssen 2009 Intervention does not contain exercise.
Hawkes 2009 Intervention does not contain exercise.
Heldal 2000 No useful outcome data reported.
Houle 2011 No outcomes of interest.
Huerre 2010 Not an RCT.
Jiang 2007 No useful outcome data reported
Karpova 2009 Not an RCT.
Kavanagh 1973 No outcomes of interest.
Kentala 1972 Not an RCT.
Kim 2011 Not an RCT.
Kim 2012 Not an RCT.
Kim 2013 Not an RCT.
Krachler 1997 No useful outcome data reported.
Kubilius 2012 Not an RCT.
Lee 2013 Not an RCT.
Li 2004 Follow up < 6 months.
Liao 2003 Follow‐up too short (3 to 4 weeks) and no useful outcome data reported.
Lie 2009 Intervention does not contain exercise.
Mameletzi 2011 No outcomes of interest.
Mandic 2013 Not an RCT.
Martinez 2011 No outcomes of interest.
Mayer‐Berger 2014 Comparator received exercise.
Mezey 2008 Not an RCT.
Mohammed 2012 No outcomes of interest.
Moholdt 2012a Comparator received exercise.
Moholdt 2012b Comparator received exercise.
Molino‐Lova 2013 Participants had already received rehabilitation.
Murphy 2012 Partcipants did not have CHD.
Pater 2000 Authors did not respond to repeated requests for study update.
Pedersen 2013 Comparator received exercise.
Peschel 2007 No useful outcome data reported.
Piestrzeniewicz 2004 No useful outcome data reported.
Pluss 2011 Comparator received exercise.
Poortaghi 2011 No outcomes of interest.
Poortaghi 2013 Comparator received exercise.
Ribeiro 2012 Follow up only 8 weeks.
Rideout 2012 Intervention does not contain exercise.
Roviaro 1984 Not an RCT.
Sadeghi 2013 Follow up only 8 weeks.
Sagar 2012 Comparator received exercise.
Sato 2010 No outcomes of interest.
Sawatzky 2014 Follow up only 3 months.
Schumacher 2006 No useful outcome data reported.
Schwaab 2011 Not an RCT.
Shabani 2010 Follow up only 12 weeks.
Shikhova 2010 Not an RCT.
Siqueira‐Catania 2013 Participants did not have CHD.
Soleimannejad 2014 No outcomes of interest.
Stahle 1999 Follow up only 3 months.
Stenlund 2005 No useful outcome data reported.
Takeyama 2000 No useful outcome data reported.
Tokmakidis 2003 No useful outcome data reported.
Turkstra 2013 Intervention does not contain exercise.
Uhlemann 2012 Comparator received exercise.
Walters 2010 Comparator received exercise.
Wood 2008 No outcomes of interest.
Wosornu 1996 No useful outcome data reported.
Yonezawa 2009 Not an RCT.
Zheng 2008 No useful outcome data reported.
Zhu 2013 Intervention does not include exercise.