Identification

Study ID

Title

Journal

Authors

Year of publication

Medline ID

Volume, Issue e page

Language

Design study

Participants

Total

PS

T‐Tube

1. N

2. Age

3. Gender                 (Men)                                   (Women)

4. Inclusion criteria

5. Exclusion criteria

6. Time of MV before trial (hours or days)

7. Translaryngeal or tracheotomy tube

8. Score Health

9. Similarity between groups

10. Notes

Interventions

Number of interventions

1.  Intervention in experimental Group 1 (PS)

Pressure support level (cmH2O)

Duration of SBT (30, 60, 120min or other)

FiO2

2.  Intervention in experimental Group 2 (T‐tube)

T‐tube (T‐piece)

Duration of SBT(30, 60,120min  or other)

O2 L/min

Methods

1.Statistical Analysis (mean/ median)

2. Sample size calculation

3. Intention‐to‐treat analysis

Risk of Bias

Bias

Authors Judgement

Support for Judgement

Adequate sequence generation?

Allocation concealment?

Free of selective reporting?

Free of detection bias?

Free of attrition bias?

Free of other bias?

Outcomes measured

Weaning processes

Simple weaning

Difficult weaning

Prolonged weaning

Outcomes

PS

T‐tube

PS

T‐tube

PS

T‐tube

1‐ Time of weaning from MV

2‐ ICU mortality

3‐ Hospital mortality

4‐ Weaning success (successful extubation)

5‐ Reintubation

6‐ Tracheostomy

7‐ ICU Length of stay

8‐ Hospital Length of stay

9‐ Pneumonia

10‐ Duration of mechanical ventilation

11‐ Adverse events

12‐ Quality of life

13‐ Successful spontaneous breathing trial

14‐ Respiratory Rate (RR)

15‐ Tidal Volume( VT)

16‐ Oxygenation index

17‐ Pi max

18‐ Rapid and shallow breathing index (RSBI)