Skip to main content
. 2018 Mar 1;2018(3):CD001120. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001120.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Afonso 2009 Older population with no diagnosis of dementia.
Akhoondzadeh 2014 Healthy older adults and no control group.
Allen 2014 Not specific to dementia.
Asiret 2016 Not an RCT. Authors stated "Patients were listed through their mini mental test scores, and randomized as odd numbers to control group and even numbers to intervention group." This is allocation rather than randomisation.
Baillon 2004 Only 3 sessions of reminiscence therapy. No control group.
Baillon 2005 Only 3 sessions of reminiscence therapy. No control group.
Barban 2016 Reminiscence therapy combined with process‐based cognitive training.
Bogaert 2013 Inadequate generation of a randomised sequence meaning study was not an RCT.
Bohlmeijer 2008 Not specific to dementia.
Brooker 2000 Not an RCT.
Burckhardt 1987 Not an intervention study and not specific to reminiscence and dementia.
Chao 2006 An MMSE score < 24 was an exclusion criteria, i.e. population did not have a clear diagnosis of dementia.
Chenoweth 2009 Not reminiscence therapy.
Chiang 2010 MMSE score > 20 was necessary to be included in the study, i.e. population did not have a clear diagnosis of dementia.
Choy 2016 Participants did not have dementia.
Chueh 2014 No mention of diagnosis of dementia.
Chung 2009 Single group experimental design, i.e. not an RCT.
Crook 2016 Not an RCT.
Curto Prieto 2015 No passive control group.
Eritz 2016 Study used a life history intervention which was not carried out directly with the person with dementia
Gudex 2010 Residential home population that specifically excluded residents with severe dementia. No diagnostic information provided; no data given for people with dementia.
Haight 2003 Randomisation not mentioned
Haslam 2010 Comparison was against an activity (playing skittles) rather than no treatment/social contact.
Haslam 2014 No passive control condition.
Head 1990 No randomisation.
Hilgeman 2014 Mixed intervention, mostly focusing on advance care planning.
Hsu 2009 Population did not have a clear diagnosis of dementia.
Hutson 2014 Not sufficient reminiscence therapy content.
Jo 2015 Not an RCT.
Lalanne 2015 Control condition was a cognitive training programme.
Lancioni 2014 Feasibility study, not an RCT.
Lin 2011 Not an RCT.
Liu 2007 Excluded people with a diagnosis of dementia.
Lopes 2016 Inclusion criteria appeared to include people with MCI, according to cut‐off scores on Montreal Cognitive Assessment which is used to determine eligibility for the study. Data not available separately for participants meeting criteria for mild dementia. Less than 10% of participants had formal diagnosis of dementia.
MacKinlay 2009 Qualitative study.
Mackinlay 2010 Intervention was not reminiscence therapy.
McKee 2003 Reminiscence used with a general care home population. Data for people with dementia not presented separately.
McMurdo 2000 Residential home population with MMSE score >12; no diagnostic information provided; no data given for people with dementia.
Melendez‐Moral 2013 Not specific to dementia.
Morris 2015 No mention of dementia.
Nakamae 2014 Not sufficient reminiscence therapy content, correspondence with authors stated that participants engaged in 5 minutes of reminiscence per session.
Nakatsuka 2015 Only included participants with MCI.
Orten 1989 Population without clear diagnosis of dementia.
Politis 2004 Not enough reminiscence therapy content
Rattenbury 1989 Cognitive impairment was an exclusion factor for this study, i.e. population did not have a clear diagnosis of dementia.
Rawtaer 2015 Inclusion criteria include MMSE of ≥ 24, i.e. not a population with dementia.
Sabir 2016 People with dementia excluded.
Serrano 2004 Diagnosis of dementia was an exclusion factor.
Stinson 2006 Significant cognitive impairment was an exclusion factor for this study, i.e. population did not have a clear diagnosis of dementia.
Tadaka 2004 Study used the same participants and measures as the Tadaka 2007 (AD); Tadaka 2007 (VD) studies which were included in this review. The 2004 version was excluded to avoid double counting the same data in the analysis.
Tanaka 2017 Intervention includes reality orientation and physical exercise as well as reminiscence. Described as cognitive rehabilitation.
Thornton 1987 Not an intervention study.
Tolson 2012 Intervention was not reminiscence therapy.
Van Dijk 2012 Not enough reminiscence therapy (1 session only).
Wang 2004 Cognitive impairment was an exclusion factor for this study, i.e. population did not have a clear diagnosis of dementia.
Wang 2007 Inadequate generation of a randomised sequence meaning not an RCT.
Wang 2009 Inadequate generation of a randomised sequence meaning not an RCT.
Wingbermuehle 2014 Not an intervention study.
Wu 2016 Intervention described as spiritual reminiscence but the content does not reflect reminiscence work.
Yamagami 2007 Not an RCT.
Yasuda 2009 1 group, not an RCT.
Yousefi 2015 No mention of dementia in paper.
Zauszniewski 2004 A diagnosis of dementia was an exclusion factor for this study.

MCI: mild cognitive impairment; MMSE: Mini‐Mental State Examination; RCT: randomised controlled trial.