Skip to main content
. 2018 Apr 5;2018(4):CD008509. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008509.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Agarwal 2009 MET adjunct therapy to ESWL.
Aravinthan 2012 Stones larger than 10 mm were included, and data could not be separated for adequate analysis of stones measuring 10 mm or less.
Avdoshin 2005 Stones larger than 10 mm were included, and separate data were not available for stones measuring 10 mm or less.
Aydogdu 2009 Participants were children.
Bak 2007 No extracted data were available.
Bhat 2015 Prospective study, but unclear whether this study was randomised.
Borghi 1994 Intervention was calcium channel blocker.
Brausi 2015 No randomisation was performed.
Chau 2011 Patients with pyelonephritis were included.
Cooper 2000 Intervention was calcium channel blocker.
Cuni 2013 Use of Rowatinex/Terpenes vs tamsulosin without control or placebo group.
Damiano 2008 Participants were patients who had undergone ureteral stent positioning.
Deliveliotis 2006 Participants were patients with stone‐related hydronephrosis who had opted for conservative management with insertion of a double‐J ureteral stent.
Dellabella 2003 Stones larger than 10 mm were included, and separate data were not available for stones measuring 10 mm or less.
Dellabella 2005 Stones larger than 10 mm were included, and separate data were not available for stones measuring 10 mm or less.
Dellabella 2005a The intervention comprised corticosteroids added to 1 of 2 tamsulosin groups.
Gandhi 2013 Stones larger than 10 mm were included, and separate data were not available for stones measuring 10 mm or less.
Gupta 2013 Tamsulosin vs silodosin. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
Gupta Shyam 2014 Tamsulosin vs herbal preparation. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
Gurbuz 2011 Hyoscine‐N‐butylbromide (antispasmodic drug) vs alfuzosin vs doxazosin vs terazosin. HBB was not given to alpha‐blocker groups. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
Haxhiu 2014 Unclear Results section. Data not interpretable.
Hwang 2012 Retrospective study.
Imperatore 2014 Tamsulosin vs silodosin. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
ISRCTN24675122 Study closed in January 2011 owing to insufficient recruitment.
Itano 2012 Retrospective study.
Jayant 2014 Tamsulosin vs tamsulosin and tadalafil. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
John 2010 Participants were patients with large renal or ureteral calculi who underwent ureteroscopic laser lithotripsy.
Khawaja 2005 Patients with multiple stones were included.
Kumar 2014 Tamsulosin vs tamsulosin and tadalafil. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
Kumar 2015 Tamsulosin and prednisolone vs naftopidil and prednisolone vs watchful waiting (no prednisolone). Therapy groups cannot be compared with watchful waiting group because prednisolone was used by treatment groups. Every positive effect reported in the therapy group could be due to use of prednisolone instead of the alpha‐blocker.
Loftus 2015 Retrospective study.
Lu 2012 Naftopidil vs naftopidil and tolterodine vs tolterodine. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
Mohseni 2006 Stones larger than 10 mm were included, and separate data were not available for stones measuring 10 mm or less.
Moon 2015 Retrospective study.
Morozumi 2013 Naftopidil vs buscopan group. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
Multescu 2014 Retrospective study. Not an RCT.
Nasim 2014 Retrospective study.
Ohgaki 2010 Data on primary and secondary outcomes not available.
Porpiglia 2000 Intervention was calcium channel blocker.
Ramesh 2015 No information on inclusion and exclusion criteria available. Stones measuring > 7 mm were included; maximum diameter was unknown.
Reddy 2016 Study method is cohort; not an RCT.
Resim 2005 Stones larger than 10 mm were included; separate data were not available for stones measuring 10 mm or less.
Resorlu 2011 Investigators included no control group.
Salem 2015 Silodosin vs tamsulosin. No placebo or control group was available for comparison.
Sameer 2014 Children were included in the study (8 years old).
Shabana 2015 Tamsulosin vs alfuzosin. No placebo or control group was available for comparison.
Shah 2013 "Random base"; not an RCT.
Skrekas 2003 Intervention was calcium channel blocker.
Su 2016 Data were not consistent throughout the article. Participant numbers were different in tables as compared with the flow chart and text.
Sumer 2012 Primary outcome was resolution of colicky pain. Stone clearance rate was not reported.
Tchey 2011 Retrospective study.
Tsuzaka 2011 Naftopidil vs silodosin. No placebo or control group available for comparison.
Vavassori 2012 No randomisation performed.
Wang 2009c Patients underwent ESWL before study entry.

ESWL: extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy; HBB: hyoscine‐N‐butylbromide; MET: medical expulsive therapy; RCT: randomised controlled trial.