Skip to main content
. 2018 May 10;2018(5):CD012069. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012069.pub2

Steele 2006.

Methods An open‐label, 8‐week, multicentre, randomised, parallel trial with 2 arms:
  1. Osmotic release oral system (OROS) methylphenidate

  2. Usual care with immediate release (IR) methylphenidate

Participants Number of participants screened: 187
Number of participants included: 147
Number randomised to OROS‐methylphenidate: 73 and IR‐methylphenidate: 74
Number of participants followed up: OROS‐methylphenidate: 61; IR‐methylphenidate: 62
Number of withdrawals: OROS‐methylphenidate: 12; IR‐methylphenidate: 12
Diagnosis of ADHD: DSM‐IV (subtype: combined (79.3%), hyperactive‐impulsive (2.1%), inattentive (18.6%)
Age: mean: not stated (range: 6‐12)
IQ: above 70
Sex: 121 males, 24 females
Methylphenidate‐naïve: not stated
Ethnicity: white: 86.9%, African American: 3.4%, Asian: 0.7%, others: 9.0%
Country: Canada
Comorbidity: oppositional defiant disorder (40.7%), conduct disorder (0.7%), anxiety (4.1%)
Comedication: not stated
Sociodemographics: not stated
Inclusion criteria:
  1. Physically healthy

  2. Aged 6‐12 years inclusive

  3. ADHD diagnosis according to DSM‐IV

  4. Medication naïve or currently on ADHD medication therapy

  5. A baseline Clinical Global Impression‐Severity (CGI‐S) score of 4 or greater (at least 'moderate' severity)

  6. Had to demonstrate significant after‐school/evening behavioural difficulties as assessed by the clinician via parent/child interviews

  7. To approximate clinical practice settings, psychotropic medications to treat non‐ADHD disorders and psychological interventions were permitted as long as the treatment/intervention had been stable for a minimum of 4 weeks prior to entry and did not change nor newly commence during the trial


Exclusion criteria:
  1. Known methylphenidate non‐responders, hypersensitivity, or adversely affected by methylphenidate

  2. Concomitant use of contraindicated medication likely to interfere with the safe administration of study medication

  3. Marked anxiety, tension, aggression/agitation

  4. Glaucoma

  5. Ongoing seizure disorder

  6. Psychotic disorder

  7. Diagnosis or family history of Tourette disorder

  8. Bipolar disorder

  9. Suspected mental retardation or significant learning disorder

  10. Medication/alcohol abuse/dependence by either the child or parent

  11. History of, or current eating disorder

  12. Severe gastrointestinal narrowing

  13. Inability to swallow study medications

  14. And any serious/unstable medical illness

Interventions Methylphenidate type: osmotic release oral system and immediate release methylphenidate (patients were randomly assigned)
Mean daily dose of OROS‐methylphenidate: 37.8 (SD 11.9) mg (1.17 (SD 0.52) mg/kg; range 18‐54 mg)
Mean daily dose of IR‐methylphenidate: 33.3 (SD 13.2) mg (1.03 (SD 0.46) mg/kg; range 10‐70 mg)
Administration schedule: OROS‐methylphenidate once daily in the morning and IR‐methylphenidate 2‐3 times daily
Duration of intervention: 8 weeks
Titration period: 4 weeks initiated after randomisation
Washout: at study entry, patients on stimulant or non‐stimulant medication to treat ADHD underwent a minimum 3‐day washout
Treatment compliance: the percentage of participants who missed any dose during the trial: IR‐methylphenidate (84%) and OROS‐methylphenidate (56%)
Outcomes Non‐serious adverse events:
Adverse events, physical examination, vital signs, and body weight, height
Notes Sample calculation: yes (130 participants)
Ethics approval: yes
Funding/vested interest: this research was supported by Janssen‐Ortho Inc., Canada
Authors' affiliations: no affiliations to pharmaceutical companies stated
Key conclusions of the study authors: once‐daily OROS‐methylphenidate is significantly more effective than usual care with IR‐methylphenidate based on multiple outcome measures including remission rate
Exclusion of methylphenidate non‐responders: yes, known non‐responders excluded (see exclusion criteria 1)
Supplemental information requested through email correspondence with the authors in September 2013. No reply