Table 2. Cognitive screenings,procedures for determining validity/reliability.
Cognitive screening | Procedures for determining validity/reliability with appropriate values |
Procedures for determining validity/reliability without appropriate values |
---|---|---|
Addenbrooke's Cognitive Examination-Revised (ACE-R) | SE/SP (relationships with criteria)13 | |
Barrow Neurological Institute Screen for Higher Cerebral Functions (BNIS) | Concurrent validity (relation with criteria),27 , 28 SE (relation with criteria),27 convergent validity (relation with related constructs),27 , 28 correlation (internal consistence reliability),27 , 28 comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria).28 | SP (relation with criteria)27 |
Birmingham Cognitive Screen (BCoS - Cantonese version) | Inter-rater (internal-consistency reliability),29 test-retest (temporal stability reliability),29 comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),29 convergent validity (relation with related constructs).29 | |
Birmingham Cognitive Screen (BCoS) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),30 predictive validity (relation with criteria).30 | |
Brief Memory and Executive Test (BMET) | Inter-rater (internal consistency reliability),31 test-retest (temporal stability reliability),31 SE/SP (relation with criteria),31 comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),31 response times (response processes).31 | |
Brief Neuropsychological Screening (BNS) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),32 predictive validity (relation with criteria),32 convergent validity (relationship with related constructs). 32 | |
Clock Drawing Test (CDT) | SE/SP (relation with criteria)33 | Convergent validity (relation with related constructs),7SE/SP (relation with criteria).7 |
Cog-4 | Convergent validity (relation with related constructs),34 SE/SP (relation with criteria).34 | |
Cognistat | Convergent validity (relation with related constructs),7 SE/SP (relation with criteria).7 | |
Cognitive Assessment Scale for Stroke Patients (CASP) | Convergent validity (relation with related constructs).35 , 36 | |
Functional Independence Measure (FIM cognitive) | Convergent validity (relationship with related constructs)37 | |
Middlesex Elderly Assessment of Mental State (MEAMS) | SE/SP (relation with criteria)38 | |
Mild Vascular Cognitive Impairment Assessment tool for Stroke (MVCI) | Judge analysis - face validity (content-oriented evidence),39 convergent validity (relation with related constructs),39 SE/SP (relation with criteria),39 correlation,inter-rater (internal consistency reliability).39 | |
Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),16 , 24 , 41 , 45 , 46 SE (relation with criteria),42SE/SP (relation with criteria),43 , 46 predictive validity (relation with criteria),24concurrent validity (relation with criteria),45convergent validity (relation with related constructs).16,45 | SE/SP (relation with criteria),6 convergent validity (relation with related constructs),37 , 40 predictive validity (relation with criteria),42 , 44 SP(relation with criteria),42 SE (relation with criteria).24 , 45 |
Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria), 20 , 24 , 45 , 46 , 49 , 53 , 58 , 61SE/SP (relation with criteria),18 , 43 , 45 , 46 , 54 , 56 , 57 , 58 , 59 , 61 SE (relation with criteria), 12 , 24 , 48 , 49 , 62 SP(relation with criteria),20convergent validity (relation with related constructs),20 , 45 , 49 , 53 , 55 , 56 , 61 inter-rater (internal-consistency reliability),20 , 55 , 61 predictive validity (relation with criteria),18 , 24 , 26 , 42concurrent validity (relation with criteria),45 , 53 , 61correlation (internal consistence reliability),55test-retest (temporal stability reliability). 55 , 61 | Concurrent validity (relation with criteria),12 , 47 SP(relation with criteria),12 , 42 , 48 , 49 , 62 SE (relation with criteria),20predictive validity (relation with criteria),25 , 50convergent validity (relation with related constructs).59 |
miniMoCA | SE/SP (relation with criteria),51convergent validity (relation with related constructs). 51 | |
MoCA (by telephone) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),19 , 60 SE/SP (relation with criteria),19 , 52 , 60 convergent validity (relation with related constructs),60 concurrent validity (relation with criteria),60test-retest (temporal stability reliability),60inter-rater (internal consistency reliability).60 | |
Northwick Park Examination of Cognition (NPEC) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),63SE/SP (relation with criteria).63 | |
Oxford Cognitive Screen (OCS) | Convergent and discriminant validity (relation with related constructs),9SE/SP (relation with criteria),9 test-retest (temporal stability reliability),9 concurrent validity (relation with criteria),64 comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria).64 | |
Repeatable Battery for Assessment of Neuropsychological Status (RBANS) | Convergent and discriminant validity (relation with related constructs),65 predictive validity (relation with criteria).65 | |
Rotterdam CAMCOG (R-CAMCOG) | Convergent validity (relation with related constructs)37 | |
Screening Instrument for Neuropsychological Impairments in Stroke (SINS) | Convergent validity (relation with related constructs)7 | SE/SP (relation with criteria)7 |
Six-item Screener (SIS - by telephone) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria)19 | SE/SP (relation with criteria)19 |
Zürich Maxi Mental Status Inventory (ZüMAX) | Comparison between contrasting groups (relation with criteria),67 test-retest (temporal stability reliability).67 |
SE: sensitivity, SP: specificity.