Table 3.
ALC | Placebo | ||||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Subgroup (diabetes) | Baseline | Reduction | Reduction % | N | Baseline | Reduction | Reduction % | N | MD % (95% CI) |
De Grandis, 2002 | – | −1.93±2.09 | −39.4±42.7 | 95 | – | −0.35±1.10 | −7.7±24.2 | 104 | −31.7 (−41.5; −21.9) |
Sima UC, 2005 | 5.99±2.41 | −2.55±2.87 | −42.6±48.0 | 70 | 5.04±2.19 | −0.97±3.11 | −19.3±61.7 | 48 | −23.3 (−44.1; −2.5) |
Sima UCE, 2005 | 5.69±2.69 | −2.17±3.46 | −38.2±60.8 | 58 | 5.32±2.60 | −1.45±2.75 | −27.3±51.7 | 61 | −11.0 (−31.3; 9.4) |
Pooled analysis | 223 | 213 | −24.6 (−36.8; −12.4) |
Notes: Test for heterogeneity: τ2=50.28; χ2=3.40, df=2 (P=0.18); I2=41.2%. Test for overall effect: Z =3.95 (P<0.0001). Test for subgroup differences: χ2=2.31, df=1 (P=0.13); I2=56.7%. Results are expressed as mean ± SD. Heterogeneity indexes: χ2, τ2, I2.
Abbreviation: ALC, acetyl-L-carnitine.