Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 4;9(4):e027241. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2018-027241

Table 4.

Levels of evidence rating for the quality of the psychometric properties

Level Rating* Criteria†
Strong +++ or − − − Test‡ was evaluated in multiple studies of adequate risk of bias score or one study of very good risk of bias score (implying a low risk of bias).
Moderate ++ or − − − Test was evaluated in multiple studies of doubtful risk of bias score or one study of adequate risk of bias score.
Limited + or − − − Test was evaluated in one study of doubtful risk of bias score.
Conflicting ± Test was evaluated in studies with contradictory findings.
Unknown ? Test was evaluated in studies of inadequate risk of bias score or not investigated at all.

Adapted from Kroman et al.54

*Sufficient (+), indeterminate (?), or insufficient (-) rating.53

†Modified using the new 4-point scoring system of the updated COSMIN checklist.38

‡A specific knee proprioception test.