Table 2. Comparison of live C loss in bole (Tg C yr−1) for the conterminous United States from this study and a sample of previous estimatesa.
Source | Bole C removed | Periods |
---|---|---|
Hurtt et al., 200224 | 92C | 1980s |
King et al., 200717 | 145C | 1980s |
Pacala et al., 20018 | 92C | 1980s |
Turner et al., 199512 | 124 | 1980s |
Birdsey & Heath, 199525 | 126 | 1990 |
Heath & Smith, 200414 | 105 | 1990s |
Houghton, 199913 | 92C | 1990s |
EPA, 200826 | 132C | 2005 |
Williams et al., 201216 | 107 | 2005 |
Woodbury et al., 200715 | 132C | 2005 |
Average of previous studies | 115 ± 19d | — |
This study + western US | 104 + 24b | 2002–2010 |
aThe bole C loss refers to the C of sound cubic-foot volume that is assumed to have been taken off site and entrained into wood products, equal to the C of volume removed used by the previous studies.
bWe estimated the total C loss of bole in the conterminous United States by assuming the removals in the western United States accounted for 19% of the total removals in the conterminous United States as proposed by Oswalt et al.23.
cThe estimates were derived from a synthesis by Williams et al.16.
dMean estimate ± Standard error.