Skip to main content
. 2018 Jul 23;2018(7):CD003477. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003477.pub4
Study Reason for exclusion
Arroyo‐Anlló 2013 Not clear whether it was an RCT and the outcome was self‐consciousness.
Ballard 2009 RCT, no music‐based therapeutic intervention. A small proportion of the study sample (35) followed individualised music as an intervention. There was a non‐significant improvement on the total CMAI score.
Brotons 2000 Only 4 therapy sessions
Bruer 2007 RCT, cross‐over, 8 weeks, comparison of group music therapy to video presentation on cognition (MMSE score). Participants were involved in < 5 sessions.
Bugos 2005 RCT, people with dementia were excluded in this study, focus on healthy older adults (effects of individualised piano instruction on executive functioning and working memory).
Chae 2015 Not an RCT
Clair 1996 Not clear if participants were randomised; and they participated in < 5 sessions.
Cohen‐Mansfield 2010 Not an RCT, no control group included
Davidson 2011 Not an RCT, no control group included
Garland 2007 RCT, cross‐over, comparing audiotapes with simulated family presence to audiotapes with preferred music and a neutral placebo tape to reduce agitation. < 5 sessions in each group, in which participants listened to preferred music.
Gerdner 2000 The analyses covered directly observed agitation, probably over the combined sessions (so inclusive of the first 4 sessions).
Groene 1993 Control group also received music therapy
Hanser 1994 RCT, participants did not have dementia but depression
Hicks‐Moore 2008 RCT, comparison of favourite music and hand massage, < 5 sessions
Hokkanen 2008 RCT, no music therapy, study involved dance and movement therapeutic methods
Holmes 2006 RCT, comparison of live interactive music, passive prerecorded music or silence for 30 minutes in a single session. < 5 sessions.
Janata 2012 The intervention did not meet our criteria for a therapeutic‐based intervention in which contact with a therapist or facilitator is essential. The intervention created "a musical atmosphere" with music programmes streamed to the rooms of participants assigned to a music group for several hours per day.
Kwak 2016 RCT, only music listening, no music therapist or interaction.
Low 2016 The control of this study on effects of dance involved music appreciation and socialisation groups. There was little programming and therefore the control group did not qualify as music therapy.
Noice 2009 RCT, no music therapy: a theatrically based intervention was given to 122 older adults who took lessons twice a week for 4 weeks.
Otto 1999 RCT, participants did not have dementia.
Pomeroy 1993 RCT, music was part of physiotherapy.
Raglio 2008 Quasi‐randomised study.
Riegler 1980 RCT, not clear whether participants were diagnosed with dementia.
Satoh 2014 No music‐based therapeutic intervention, but physical exercise combined with music.
Sung 2006 No music‐based therapeutic intervention, but music with movement intervention.
Sánchez 2016 RCT, only music listening, no music therapist or interaction.
Särkämö 2014 No music‐based therapeutic intervention, but singing coaching for family carers and nurses, and listening to music.
Thompson 2005 RCT, single test moment, music as cue to facilitate performance on a category fluency task. No therapeutic intervention.
Van de Winckel 2004 RCT, no music‐based therapeutic intervention, but music‐based exercises.
Vanderark 1983 RCT, not clear whether participants were diagnosed with dementia.
채경숙 2015 No random allocation to music therapy or control group

CMAI: Cohen‐Mansfield Agitation Inventory; MMSE: Mini‐Mental State Examination; RCT: randomised controlled trial.