Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Aadahl 2015 | Not conducted in a workplace setting. Did not report workplace sitting, only total sitting. |
Adams 2012 | Not all the participants were working. Did not report workplace sitting as a separate outcome. Total sitting time reported. |
Aittasalo 2004 | Did not report workplace sitting as a separate outcome. Sitting time reported separately for working days and non‐working days but the working days included both work and leisure time. |
Alderman 2014 | Not RCT or CBA. Did not report workplace sitting. |
Arrogi 2017 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Audrey 2015 | Not conducted in a workplace setting. |
Barbieri 2017 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Ben‐Ner 2014 | Did not report data on sitting time at work separately. Daily sitting time (during waking hours) was measured with an accelerometer but it included both work and leisure time. |
Berberien 2016 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Biddle 2015 | Not conducted in a workplace setting. |
Bird 2014 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Bjorklund 2015 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Boreham 2005 | This was a stair‐climbing training study that took place during working hours, but sitting time was not assessed. |
Bouchard 2015 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Brown 2012 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
Buchholz 2016 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Carr 2013 | No data reported for sitting time at work. Daily sedentary time (criterion: 0 steps/minute) was measured with StepWatch (accelerometer attached on ankle), but it included both work and leisure time (the monitor was kept during all wakeful hours for 7 consecutive days). Correspondence with the author was unclear regarding the distinction between work and leisure in sitting time. It is also not clear what the StepWatch measures as an accelerometer. |
Carter 2015 | Not RCT or CBA. Does not describe a full working day. |
Chae 2015 | Not RCT or CBA (pre‐post design). All the participants did not complete the program. |
Cheema 2013 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
Chia 2015 | Did not report workplace sitting. Following correspondence with authors they replied: "We did not specifically measure sitting time but had an indication of the time spent in the office (these are desk bound participants‐ when they filled in the questionnaire of alertness by the hour (0900‐1700hrs)". |
Cifuentes 2015 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Clemes 2014 | Not RCT or CBA. Pedometers were used to record sitting time and step counts. |
DeCocker 2015 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Dewa 2009 | Did not report workplace sitting. Sitting time was assessed (IPAQ) but it included both work and leisure time. |
Elmer 2014 | Not RCT or CBA. Outcome is energy expenditure not time spent sitting at work. |
Engelen 2017 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Fennell 2017 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Foley 2016 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Freak‐Poli 2011 | Not an RCT or CBA. Workplace sitting not reported. Sitting time was questioned separately for weekdays and weekend days but it included both work and leisure. |
Ganesan 2016 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Gardner 2015 | Not conducted in a workplace setting. |
Gilson 2012 | Not an RCT or CBA. Did not report workplace sitting. |
Gilson 2015 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Gilson ND 2012 | Not an RCT or CBA. |
Gorman 2013 | Not an RCT or CBA. |
Green 2016 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Grunseit 2012 | Not an RCT or CBA. |
Hadgraft 2017 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Hedge 2004 | Sitting time was not reported in hours (only %). The length of intervention was not the same for everybody (no detailed information, stated “4‐6 wks”). |
Irvine 2011 | Not an RCT or CBA. No quantitative data on sitting time at work. |
Jancey 2016 | Not RCT or CBA. |
John 2011 | Not an RCT or CBA. Did not report workplace sitting. Daily sitting time (waking hours) was measured with an accelerometer, but it included both work and leisure time. |
Jones 2017 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Júdice 2015 | Did not report workplace sitting, only total sitting time. |
Kennedy 2007 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
Kerr 2016 | Not conducted in a workplace setting. |
Koepp 2013 | Not an RCT or CBA. |
Lara 2008 | Not an RCT or CBA. Did not report workplace sitting. |
Liu 2016 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Maeda 2014 | Not RCT or CBA. Participants were university students. |
Mahmud 2015 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Mainsbridge 2014 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
Mair 2014 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
Marshall 2003 | Did not report workplace sitting. Sitting time was assessed (IPAQ, short version) but it included both work and leisure time (reported as ‘weekday sitting time’). |
McAlpine 2007 | Not a normal working day, but an experimental office facility. Not an RCT or CBA. |
Miyachi 2015 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
NCT01221363 | Following correspondence with the authors, they replied: "Ours is not a work place intervention study, but a 'total sitting time' community‐based intervention study where the individual behavioural intervention addresses all domains of life, i.e. leisure time, work, transportation etc. Approximately 1/3 of participants are not working (retired or unemployed) and those who do work, do not necessarily have sedentary work, since our main inclusion criterion was minimum 3.5 hours of leisure time sitting/day. Consequently our primary outcome measure is objectively measured total daily sitting time (activPAL), and we only have rather crude self‐report measures on sitting time at work." |
Ognibene 2016 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Opdenacker 2008 | Did not report workplace sitting. Sitting time was assessed (IPAQ) but it included both work and leisure time. |
Ouyang 2015 | Not conducted in a workplace setting. Participants were sedentary overweight females. |
Parry S 2013 | Did not report workplace sitting. Reported sedentary time measured by accelerometer. Sedentary time was defined as an activity having less than 100 counts on an accelerometer. |
Pilcher 2017 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Poirier 2016 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Pronk 2012 | Not an RCT or CBA. |
Roossien 2017 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Schwartz 2016 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Slootmaker 2009 | Did not report workplace sitting. Daily sitting time (waking hours) was measured with an accelerometer, but it included both work and leisure time. |
Sternfeld 2009 | Did not report workplace sitting. Sedentary time assessed during leisure. |
Straker 2013 | Not an RCT or CBA. |
Taylor 2016 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Thogersen‐Ntoumani 2013 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
Thompson 2014 | Did not report workplace sitting. The authors used accelerometers, but converted their results into energy expenditure/day (no separation between work and leisure time). |
Thorp 2015 | Outcome is energy expenditure not time spent sitting at work. |
Torbeyns 2016 | Did not report workplace sitting |
Torbeyns 2017 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Tucker 2016 | Did not report workplace sitting |
vanNassau 2015 | Not RCT or CBA. |
Wirick 2016 | Not conducted in a workplace setting. |
Yancey 2004 | Did not report workplace sitting. |
Østerås 2005 | Not an RCT or CBA. |
Abbreviations
CBA: controlled before‐and‐after study IPAQ: International physical activity questionnaire RCT: randomised controlled trial