Skip to main content
. 2018 Jun 4;2018(6):CD008687. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008687.pub2

Lee 2014.

Methods Parallel‐group randomised controlled trial
Participants Baseline characteristics
Number randomised: 60 participants
Number analysed: 60 participants
Esomeprazole
  • Age (years; mean (SD)): 56.2 (18.4)

  • Number of participants at baseline (n): 30

  • Gender (male/female; n): 20/10


Famotidine
  • Age (years; mean (SD)): 59.2 (15.0)

  • Number of participants at baseline (n): 30

  • Gender (male/female; n): 16/14


Inclusion criteria
  • Age ≥ 18 years

  • Admitted to ICU or management of severe cerebrovascular accident


Exclusion criteria
  • Age < 18 years

  • History of allergy to either famotidine or esomeprazole

  • Feeding through a nasogastric tube not possible

  • Having gastrointestinal bleeding on admission


Baseline imbalances: no significant difference for sex, age, GCS, AP‐II, intracranial pressure, and operation time between these 2 groups
Interventions Esomeprazole
  • Dose (total/d): 40 mg

  • Duration of treatment (days): 7

  • Route: nasogastric tube

  • Intervention: 40 mg (Nexium, AstraZeneca, Sodertaije, Sweden) dissolved in water through a nasogastric tube once per day for 7 days

  • Concomitant medications: Every patient received ventilator support and nasogastric feeding when admitted to the ICU


Famotidine
  • Dose (total/d): 40 mg

  • Duration of treatment (days): 7

  • Route: IV

  • Intervention: intravenous famotidine (20 mg, Gaster, Astellas, Shizuoka, Japan) infusion every 12 hours for 7 days

  • Concomitant medications: Every patient received ventilator support and nasogastric feeding when admitted to the ICU


Adherence to regimen:
Duration of trial: March 2007 to March 2010
Duration of follow‐up: 30 days
Outcomes Outcomes sought in review and reported in trial
  • GI bleeding (overt or occult) defined as tarry stool, haematemesis, drainage of more than 60 mL 'coffee ground' substance from nasogastric tube, or decreased haemoglobin level > 2 g/dL with proven lesions by endoscopic examination. We also defined positive stool occult blood test as occult bleeding

  • Ventilator‐associated pneumonia defined as pneumonia occurring after 48 hours of ventilator use that fulfils ≥ 3 of the following 4 criteria: (1) presence of persistent (> 48 hours) or new‐onset infiltration in CXR; (2) positive sputum smear (with < 10 epithelial cells per low‐power field, 100×, and > 25 white blood cells per low‐power field or presence of polymorphonuclear cells with phagocytosis); (3) fever with body temperature > 38.3°C; and (4) leucocytosis > 12 × 109/L

  • Mortality (30 days)

  • Duration of ICU stay


Outcomes sought in review but not reported in trial
  • Blood transfusion

  • Adverse events of interventions

  • Duration of intubation


Outcome reported in trial but not used in review
  • 30‐Day survival

Notes Setting: Neurosurgical ICU, Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Department of Internal Medicine, Far Eastern Memorial Hospital, New Taipei, Taiwan
Source of funding: Quote: "This study was performed in the Far Eastern Memorial Hospital and was supported by the research grant FEMH‐94‐C‐016 from the Far Eastern Memorial Hospital"
Conflicts of interest: Quote: "All contributing authors declare no conflicts of interest"
Ethics approval: Quote: "This study was approved by the Research Ethics Review Committee of the Far Eastern Memorial Hospital"
Informed consent: Quote: "After explaining the study purpose and obtaining written consent from their family members"
Clinical trials registration:
Sample size calculation:
Sponsorship source: supported by the research grant FEMH‐94‐ C‐016 from the Far Eastern Memorial Hospital
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Random sequence generation (selection bias) Unclear risk Quote: "The patients were randomly allocated to two groups"
Comment: not enough details reported
Allocation concealment (selection bias) Unclear risk Comment: no details reported
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) 
 All outcomes Low risk Comment: no details on blinding reported, but lack of blinding is unlikely to introduce bias to the outcomes or outcome measures
Blinding (detection bias) 
 Clinically important upper GI bleeding Low risk Quote: "[We] defined upper gastrointestinal bleeding as tarry stool, haematemesis, drainage of more than 60 mL coffee
 ground substance from nasogastric tube, or decreased haemoglobin level more than 2 g/dL with proved lesions by
 endoscopic examination. We also defined positive stool occult blood test as occult bleeding"
Comment: Outcome was measured objectively
Blinding (detection bias) 
 Nosocomial pneumonia Low risk Quote: "We defined ventilator‐associated pneumonia as pneumonia occurring after 48 hours of ventilator use that fulfils three or more of the following four criteria: (1) presence of persistent (> 48 hours) or new onset infiltration in CXR; (2) positive sputum smear (with < 10 epithelial cells per low‐power field, 100×, and > 25 white blood cells per low‐power field or presence of polymorphonuclear cells with phagocytosis); (3) fever with body temperature > 38.3°C; and (4) leukocytosis > 12 × 10⁹/L"
Comment: Outcome was measured objectively
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) 
 Adverse reactions of interventions Unclear risk Comment: no details reported
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) 
 All outcomes Low risk Comment: no incomplete outcome data; all participants randomised at baseline were included in analyses
Selective reporting (reporting bias) Low risk Comment: no incomplete reporting of outcomes suspected. All outcomes listed in the Methods section were also reported in the Results section
Other bias Low risk Comment: no other sources of bias suspected