15. Results of cohort studies: height.
Study ID; mean age at baseline; analysis |
Outcome | Outcome units | Time point (year) | Exposure | Exposure unit | Results of association (all reported values) |
Direction;a energy intake adjusted (yes/no) |
Matched groups or adjusted for (or both) |
Height at 1 year: 2 cohort studies; 2 analyses (n ˜ 740) in children aged 2‐6 years | ||||||||
Niinikoski 1997a 2 years; mean end values per group |
Relative heightb | % | 1 | Total fat intake (single 4‐day dietary record at baseline, 1.5 and 2 years) | LF (27.7‐28.7 %TE); HF (> 28.7 %TE) |
n overall = 740 (LF = 35, HF = 705); mean end values (SD). Baseline: LF = 0.30 (0.9); HF = 0.32 (0.9). At 1 year: LF = 0.18 (1.0); HF = 0.16 (0.9); P = 0.93. After 1 year, on average children with LF intake (27.7‐28.7 %TE) have a relative height change of 0.12% compared to 0.16% for children with HF intake (> 28.7 %TE). |
‐ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
Tershakovec 1998 (cohort) 6.2 years; mean end values per group |
Height | z‐score | 1 | Total fat intake (multiple 24‐hour dietary recalls at baseline and 1 year) | LF quintile (24%TE) HF quintile (34%TE) |
n overall = NR (LF = NR, HF = NR); mean end values (SD NR). Baseline: LF = ‐0.23; HF = 0.17. At 1 year: LF = ‐0.11; HF = 0.22. After 1 year, on average children in LF intake (24%TE) quintile gain 0.12 z‐score in height while children in HF intake (34%TE) quintile gain 0.05 z‐score in height. |
+ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
Height at > 1to 2 years: 2 cohort study; 3 analysis (n = 836) in boys and girls aged 2‐4 years | ||||||||
Ambrosini 2016 3.6 years; mean end values per group |
Height | cm | 1.5 | Total fat intake (single 3‐day unweighed food record at baseline) | LF quintile (30.4%TE) HF quintile (41.8%TE) |
n boys, at baseline = 439; at 1.5 years = 387 (LF = NR, HF = NR); mean end values (SD). Baseline: LF = 99.9 (95% CI 99.2 to 100.5); HF = 99.3 (95% CI 98.7 to 99.9). At 1.5 years: LF = 110.7 (95% CI 109.9 to 111.5); HF = 109.9 (95% CI 109.1 to 110.7). After 1.5 years, on average boys with LF intake (30.4%TE) quintile gain 10.8 cm in height while boys with HF intake (41.8%TE) quintile gain 10.6 cm in height. |
‐ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
Ambrosini 2016 3.6 years; mean end values per group |
Height | cm | 1.5 | Total fat intake (single 3‐day unweighed food record at baseline) | LF quintile (30.4%TE) HF quintile (41.8%TE) |
n girls, at baseline = 351; at 1.5 years = 323) (LF = NR, HF = NR); mean end values (SD). Baseline: LF = 99.9 (95% CI 98.0 to 99.8). HF = 98.3 (95% CI 97.6 to 99.1). At 1.5 years: LF = 110.0 (95% CI 108.9 to 111.1); HF = 109.3 (95% CI 108.3 to 110.3). After 1.5 years, on average girls in LF intake (30.4%TE) quintile will gain10.1 cm in height while girls in HF intake (41.8%TE) quintile will gain 11 cm in height. |
+ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
Magarey 2001 2 years; mean end values per group |
Height | cm | 2 | Total fat intake (single 3‐day weighed dietary records at baseline and 2 years) | LF < 30%TE HF > 35%TE |
n overall = 126 (LF = 14, HF = 112); mean end values (SD). Baseline: LF = 86.1 (2.6); HF = 87.7 (3.3). At 2 years: LF (n = 20) = 107 (5.5); HF (n = 76) = 106 (3.9); P = NS. After 2 years, on average children with LF intake (< 30%TE) gain 20.9 cm in height, while children with HF intake > 35%TE) gain 18.3 cm in height. |
‐ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
Height at > 2to 5 years: 3 cohort studies; 3 analyses (n = 973) in boys and girls aged 2‐10 years | ||||||||
Shea 1993 4.4 years; mean change per group |
Height | cm/year | 2.1 | Total fat intake (multiple FFQs at baseline) | LF ≤ 30%TE HF > 30%TE |
n overall = 215 (LF = 37, HF = 178), mean change (SD). Baseline: LF = 6.8 (1.4); HF = 6.4 (0.8); P > 0.05. MD 0.2 (95% CI ‐0.24 to 0.64). After 2 years, LF intake (≤ 30%TE) will result in a 0.2 cm/year greater increase in height on average compared to HF intake (> 30%TE). |
‐ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
Obarzanek 1997 (cohort) 9.6 years regression |
Height | cm | 3 | Total fat intake (multiple 24‐hour recalls at baseline, 1 and 3 years) |
%TE | n overall = 632; regression results. B = ‐0.0009, P = 0.6. After 3 years, for every 1% increase in energy intake from fat, height in children will decrease by 0.0009 cm on average. |
‐ Yes |
Adjusted for gender, physical activity, treatment, visit number, other sources of energy than fat, and for interactions: fat intake‐by‐treatment, fat intake‐by‐gender, fat intake‐by‐visit number and visit number‐by‐treatment. |
Magarey 2001 2 years; mean end values per group |
Height | cm | 4 | Total fat intake (single 3‐day weighed dietary record at baseline, 2 and 4 years) | LF < 30%TE HF > 35%TE | n overall = 126 (LF = 14, HF = 112); mean end values (SD). Baseline: LF = 86.1 (2.6); HF = 87.7 (3.3). At 4 years: LF (n = 14) = 114 (5.5); HF (n = 88) = 116 (4.3); P > 0.05. After 4 years, on average children with LF intake (< 30%TE) gain 27.9 cm in height, while children with HF intake (> 35%TE) gain 28.3 cm in height. |
+ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
Height at > 5to 10 years: 1 cohort study; 1 analysis (n = 126) in boys and girls aged 2 years | ||||||||
Magarey 2001 2 years; mean end values per group |
Height | cm | 6 | Total fat intake (single 3‐day weighed dietary record at baseline, 2 and 4 years; single 4‐day weighed dietary record at 6 years) | LF < 30%TE HF > 35%TE | n overall = 126 (LF = 14, HF = 112); mean end values (SD). Baseline: LF = 86.1 (2.6); HF = 87.7 (3.3). At 6 years: LF (n = 13) = 131 (7.7); HF (n = 72) = 128 (5.2); P > 0.05. At 6 years, on average children in LF intake (< 30%TE) gain 44.9 cm in height while children in HF intake (> 35%TE) gain 40.3 cm in height. |
‐ No |
No matching reported. No adjustment for prognostic variables. |
aDirection refers to whether there was a positive (+: exposure and outcome moved in the same direction), inverse/negative (‐: exposure and outcome moved in opposite directions) or zero (0: no association) between total fat intake and the outcome.
bRelative height, deviation in percentages from the mean height of healthy Finnish children of the same height and gender.
%TE: percentage of total energy; FFQ: Food Frequency Questionnaire; LF: low fat; HF: high fat; MD: mean difference; NA: not applicable; NR: not reported; SD: standard deviation.