Ahmad 2015.
Methods | Prospective cohort study Setting: hospital leg ulcer clinic Country: UK Duration of follow‐up: 6 months Treatments: compression bandaging (3‐layer or 4‐layer) |
|
Participants | 30 participants with VLUs (recalcitrant ulcers) Median age (range): 62 (36‐79) years vs 70 (40‐92) years (healed vs non‐healed) Sex (M:F): 4:5 vs 10:11 (healed vs non‐healed) Stage of ulcer: not reported Ulcer duration: median (range): 12 (3‐84) months vs 19 (2‐180) months (healed vs non‐healed) Ulcer size at baseline: median (range): 6 (2‐165) cm² vs 9 (3‐140) cm² (healed vs non‐healed) Wound infection: not reported Number of wounds: 30 (if bilateral, only 1 limb assessed) Inclusion criteria: confirmed VLU; incompetence of superficial veins or thrombosed deep veins on duplex scan Exclusion criteria: ABPI < 0.8, immunosuppressed, unable to tolerate compression therapy |
|
Prognostic factors | Active uPA (continuous data); total uPA (including receptor bound and complexed to PAI‐1 and PAI‐2). Level of active uPA (quote: "below sensitivity of bioimmunoassay"). Measurement method ELISA: total uPA antigen measurements by ELISA IMUBIND (American Diagnostica). Active uPA measured by bioimmunoassay with the WHO uPA standard. Activity and antigen measurements normalised against soluble protein concentration (Coomassie Plus protein assay). Time of measurement: collected before start of compression therapy Wound fluid sampling method: occlusive dressings (exudate collected from under Opsite (Smith & Nephew) dressing) |
|
Notes | uPA activity measured too, but in all ulcer exudates the level was below the sensitivity of the bioimmunoassay. | |
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Selection bias | Unclear risk | Moderate: unclear if consecutive participants, but representative; people at a dedicated ulcer clinic (but inclusion criterion for review was any with VLU). |
Attrition bias | Low risk | No missing data |
Prognostic factor measurement | High risk | Inappropriate biomarker measure: ELISA for total uPA (including bound and complexed uPA); active bioimmunoassay with uPA WHO standard. Activity below sensitivity level |
Outcome measurement | Unclear risk | Moderate: unclear if blinded; defined as complete re‐epithelialisation after 6 months |
Adjustment factors | High risk | None of the key adjustment factors taken into account in the design or analysis |
Analysis and reporting | High risk | Results reported only for total uPA |
Overall risk of bias | High risk |