Skip to main content
. 2018 Dec 31;27(4):293–302. doi: 10.5978/islsm.27_18-RA-01

Table 1: commonly studied PSs and their photodynamic properties, *: Enterohemorrhagic E. coli.

class example charge Excitation maximum Sample (bacteria) Concentration of PS Overall efficacy Ref
Phenothiazinium Methylene blue cationic 632nm Dental plaque samples 25 µg/ml 8% (11)
Toluidine blue cationic 410nm S. mutans 100 mg/l 2–5 log10 (77, 78)
E. coli 35 µM 0.08 log10
Rose Bengal anionic 532nm E. faecalis 10 µM 4 log10 (79)
P. aeruginosa 3 log10
Dimethyl methylene blue cationic 635–652nm A. baumannii 200 µM 2 log10 (80, 81)
New methylene blue cationic 635–652nm A. baumannii 800 µM 3.2 log10 (80, 81)

Natural PSs Curcumin neutral 547nm S. mutans 0.75 to 5 g/l ≤ 3 log10 (41, 42)
L. acidophilus
Hypericin neutral 593nm S. aureus 100 nM 4–5 log10 (8284)
E. coli 1 µg/ml ≤ 0.2 log10
Flavin derivatives cationic 450nm MRSA 50 µM 5.1 log10 (85)
EHEC* 50 µM 6.5 log10

Tetra-pyrrole structures Porphyrin cationic 446nm S. aureus 10 µM 1–2 log10 (32, 86, 87)
P. aeruginosa 225 µM 4 log10
E. faecalis 100 µM No effect
Phthalocyanine Neutral 670nm A. hidrophila 2 mM ≤ 0.5 log10 (22)
Zink Pc derivatives Cationic 690 nm S. aureus 64 ng/ml 5–6 log10 (8890)
P. aeruginosa 26 µg/ml 5–6 log10
Chlorine Neutral 660nm S. aureus 10 µg/ml 5 log10 (91)
E. coli 5 µg/ml 0.75 log10
Chlorine Cationic 532nm E. coli 5 µg/ml 0.77 log10 (92)

Nano structures Fullerenes neutral 532nm S. aureus 1 µg/ml 3 log10 (93, 94)
E. coli ≤ 85%
Titanium dioxide neutral near-UV light (400) Water treatment 1 mg/ml 77–93% (95)