Skip to main content
. 2018 Oct 15;2018(10):CD012089. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD012089.pub2
Study Reason for exclusion
Adamson 2010 Unclear whether children with Down syndrome were included, compared 3 types of parent‐mediated intervention, and outcomes were only measured in terms of joint attention and not language or communication
Allen 1980 Not an RCT and did not measure language or communication skills
Allin 1988 Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication
Aparicio 2003 Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
Bagner 2007 Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication
Bagner 2016 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Baker 1980 Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial and did not target language or communication
Baker 1984 Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial and did not target language or communication
Barna 1980 Not an RCT
Barnett 1988 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Bauer 2014 Not an RCT
Bauer 2015 Not an RCT
Baxendale 2003 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Bennett 1983 Not an RCT, did not include children with Down syndrome, and did not measure language or communication
Bidder 1975 Not an RCT
Boyce 1993 Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately, and study authors did not reply to our attempts to contact them
Buschmann 2010 Not an intervention study
Campbell 1978 Not an RCT, unclear whether children with Down syndrome were included, parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
Cologon 2017 Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
Coutinho 2003 Targeted family functioning and use of support networks and not language or communication
Del Giudice 2006 The intervention was behavioural in its approach and did not provide results for language and communication separately
Estes 1984 Not an intervention study
Gibbard 1992 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Gibbard 1994 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Gibbard 2004 Not an RCT and did not include children with Down syndrome
Girolametto 1988 Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately
Haney 1993 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Hassiotis 2017 Did not measure speech, language or communication
Heifetz 1977 The intervention targeted self‐help and not language or communication
Hopman 1989 Not an intervention study
Hornby 1984 Children were not aged 0‐6 years
Hudson 1982 Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately, intervention was behavioural, and did not measure language or communication
Hwang 2013 Included only one child with Down syndrome and parent‐mediated interventions in both arms of the trial
Innocenti 1993 Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately, and study authors did not reply to our attempts to contact them
Karaaslan 2013b Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately and study authors did not reply to our attempts to contact them
Kashima 1988 The intervention targeted self‐help skills and not language or communication
Leung 2016 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Mahoney 1985b Did not include children with Down syndrome
Mahoney 1998 Not an intervention study or RTC and parent mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
McIntyre 2008 Did not include children with Down syndrome, and the intervention targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication
McNally 2008 Not an intervention study
Moxley‐Haegert 1983 Did not include children with Down syndrome
NCT02158390 Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
Niccols 2000 Not an RCT, and the intervention did not target language or communication
Pelchat 1999 Not an RCT
Pratt 2015 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Roberts 2006 Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication
Roberts 2015 Did not include children with Down syndrome
Roux 2013 Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication
Russell 2004 Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
Schoenbrodt 2016 Not an RCT and did not include children with Down syndrome
Seifer 1991 Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
Shapiro 2014 Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication
Sofronoff 2011 Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication
Tannock 1992 Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately as the data had been destroyed
Te Kaat‐van den Os 2017 Not an RCT but a systematic review
Warren 2008 The intervention had parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial
Woynaroski 2014 Parent‐mediated interventions in both arms of the trial
Wright 2017 Not an RCT

RCT: randomised controlled trial.