Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Adamson 2010 | Unclear whether children with Down syndrome were included, compared 3 types of parent‐mediated intervention, and outcomes were only measured in terms of joint attention and not language or communication |
Allen 1980 | Not an RCT and did not measure language or communication skills |
Allin 1988 | Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication |
Aparicio 2003 | Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
Bagner 2007 | Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication |
Bagner 2016 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Baker 1980 | Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial and did not target language or communication |
Baker 1984 | Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial and did not target language or communication |
Barna 1980 | Not an RCT |
Barnett 1988 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Bauer 2014 | Not an RCT |
Bauer 2015 | Not an RCT |
Baxendale 2003 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Bennett 1983 | Not an RCT, did not include children with Down syndrome, and did not measure language or communication |
Bidder 1975 | Not an RCT |
Boyce 1993 | Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately, and study authors did not reply to our attempts to contact them |
Buschmann 2010 | Not an intervention study |
Campbell 1978 | Not an RCT, unclear whether children with Down syndrome were included, parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
Cologon 2017 | Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
Coutinho 2003 | Targeted family functioning and use of support networks and not language or communication |
Del Giudice 2006 | The intervention was behavioural in its approach and did not provide results for language and communication separately |
Estes 1984 | Not an intervention study |
Gibbard 1992 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Gibbard 1994 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Gibbard 2004 | Not an RCT and did not include children with Down syndrome |
Girolametto 1988 | Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately |
Haney 1993 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Hassiotis 2017 | Did not measure speech, language or communication |
Heifetz 1977 | The intervention targeted self‐help and not language or communication |
Hopman 1989 | Not an intervention study |
Hornby 1984 | Children were not aged 0‐6 years |
Hudson 1982 | Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately, intervention was behavioural, and did not measure language or communication |
Hwang 2013 | Included only one child with Down syndrome and parent‐mediated interventions in both arms of the trial |
Innocenti 1993 | Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately, and study authors did not reply to our attempts to contact them |
Karaaslan 2013b | Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately and study authors did not reply to our attempts to contact them |
Kashima 1988 | The intervention targeted self‐help skills and not language or communication |
Leung 2016 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Mahoney 1985b | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Mahoney 1998 | Not an intervention study or RTC and parent mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
McIntyre 2008 | Did not include children with Down syndrome, and the intervention targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication |
McNally 2008 | Not an intervention study |
Moxley‐Haegert 1983 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
NCT02158390 | Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
Niccols 2000 | Not an RCT, and the intervention did not target language or communication |
Pelchat 1999 | Not an RCT |
Pratt 2015 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Roberts 2006 | Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication |
Roberts 2015 | Did not include children with Down syndrome |
Roux 2013 | Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication |
Russell 2004 | Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
Schoenbrodt 2016 | Not an RCT and did not include children with Down syndrome |
Seifer 1991 | Parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
Shapiro 2014 | Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication |
Sofronoff 2011 | Targeted problematic behaviour and not language or communication |
Tannock 1992 | Results for children with Down syndrome were not reported separately as the data had been destroyed |
Te Kaat‐van den Os 2017 | Not an RCT but a systematic review |
Warren 2008 | The intervention had parent‐mediated intervention in both arms of the trial |
Woynaroski 2014 | Parent‐mediated interventions in both arms of the trial |
Wright 2017 | Not an RCT |
RCT: randomised controlled trial.