Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Kaiser 1981 | Allocation: Randomized, table of random numbers. Participants: Patients requiring selective central venous cannulation. Interventions: Internal jugular site insertion n=49, Subclavian site insertion n=51. Substantial missing data: No description about participants' age and sex, duration of catheterization and setting. |
Senagore 1987 | Allocation: Randomized, no further details. Participants: Patients admitted to ICU and have pulmonary artery catheters placed. Interventions: Internal jugular site insertion n=26, Subclavian site insertion n=40. Outcomes: No usable data‐ no group detail about infectious complications. Substantial missing data: No description about participants' age, sex. |
Richet 1990 | Allocation: Prospective, observational study. |
Schillinger 1991 | Allocation: Prospective, observational study. |
Trottier 1995 | Allocation: Randomized. Participants: Patients from a medical‐surgical ICU requiring no emergent central venous catheterization. Interventions: Upper access site (internal jugular and subclavian vein) n=21 Lower access site (femoral vein) n=24 Outcomes: No usable data‐unclear how many participants originally randomized to internal jugular and subclavian vein group respectively. |
Goetz 1998 | Allocation: Prospective, observational study. |
Dhawan 2001 | Allocation:Prospective, observational study. |
Lorente 2005 | Allocation: Prospective observational study. |
Deshpande 2005 | Allocation: Prospective observational study. |
Torgay 2005 | Allocation: Prospective, observational study. |
Moretti 2005 | Allocation: Prospective observational study. |
Young 2005 | Allocation: Prospective, observational study. |
Araujo 2008 | Allocation: Prospective, non‐randomized, observational, study. |
Chen 2008 | Allocation: Prospective observational study. |
Cui 2008 | Allocation: Retrospective study from another report of the same study. |
Gowardman 2008 | Allocation: Prospective, observational Study. |
Moini 2009 | Allocation: Randomized. Participants: Patients requiring short‐term central venous catheterization. Interventions: Central venous group (internal jugular and subclavian vein) n=34. External jugular group n=34. Outcomes: No usable data, participants not randomized to internal jugular and subclavian vein group respectively. |
Mer 2009 | Allocation: Prospective, observational study. |
Huang 2009 | Allocation: Randomized, no further detail. Participants: Patients with various kinds of chronically renal disease. Interventions: Femoral (n=40), internal jugular (n=52), subclavian (n=53). Outcomes: No usable data‐ There were 13 participants changed their catheter in the original site through a guidewire, Huang et al added the data of second catheterization into the first catheterization, but the second catheterization was not randomized and the data for the first catheterization were not available. |
Pang 2009 | Allocation: Prospective observational study. |
Miao 2010 | Allocation: quasi‐randomized trials. Allocation by participants' own intention. |
Fan 2011 | Allocation: not randomized trial. The intervention was selected by the patient's condition. |
Wang 2011 | Allocation: quasi‐randomized trials. It allocated by the sequence. |