Skip to main content
. 2018 Dec 17;2018(12):CD003877. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003877.pub5
Study Reason for exclusion
Al‐Zahrani 2009 Cross‐over trial
Arya 2002 Participants not randomly assigned
Badalaty 1990 Cross‐over trial
Baldinelli 1989 No comparison of groups
Berge 1999 No comparison of groups
 Ages ranging from 3 to 46 years
Blake 1999 Age unclear, authors did not respond
 Review authors assumed the subjects were adults
Campbell 1998 Participants not randomly assigned (explicitly stated)
Canpolat 2017 Described as deep sedation
Cathers 2005 Cross‐over trial
Chaushu 2002 No comparison of groups
Coldwell 1999 Evaluates adverse effects only
da Costa 2007 Cross‐over trial
Dallman 2001 Cross‐ over trial
Davila 1990 Review
Doring 1985 Not comparative
Downs 1997 Cross‐over trial
Duncan 1984 Survey
Duncan 1994 No comparison of groups
Dunn‐Russell 1993 No comparison of groups
el Magboul 1995 Cross‐over trial
Erlandsson 2001 No comparison of groups
Evans 1966 Cross‐over trial
Flaitz 1985 Cross‐over trial
Fuks 1994 Cross‐over trial
Fukuta 1993 No comparison of groups
 Ages 4 to 21 years
Fukuta 1994 Ages from 5 to 20 years
Gallardo 1984 Cross‐over trial
Gamonal Aravena 1989 Cross‐over trial
Garton 1970 Review
Haas 1996 Cross‐over trial
Hall 2006 Adults
Hartgraves 1994 Cross‐over trial
Hasty 1991 Cross‐over trial
Heard 2010 Not randomised
Henry 1990 Compares scavenged/non‐scavenged groups with regard to levels of ambient nitrous oxide
Houpt 1985a Cross‐over trial
Houpt 1985b Cross‐over trial
Houpt 1989 Cross‐over trial
Houpt 1996 Cross‐over trial
Hulland 2002 Retrospective
Isik 2008 Looked at the effect of flavouring on acceptability of oral sedatives
Jensen 1998 Retrospective study
Kantovitz 2007 Cross‐over trial
Kayalibay 1987 Review
Kerins 2007 Not randomised
Kopel 1971 Not randomised
Koroluk 2000 Retrospective study
Kramer 1991a No comparison of groups
Kramer 1991b No comparison of groups
Kupietzky 1996 No relevant outcomes
Lahoud 2001 Pilot study ‐ no comparative group
Leelataweedwud 2001 Retrospective study
Leelataweewud 2000 Cross‐over trial
Lima 2003 Cross‐over trial
Lindh‐Stromberg 2001 No comparison of groups
Lindsay 1980 Cross‐over trial
Lindsay 1985 Cross‐over trial
Litman 1997 Premedication before general anaesthesia
Litman 1998 Not randomised (author contacted)
Lökken 1994 Cross‐over trial
Machen 1977 No relevant outcomes
Malamed 1989 No comparison of groups
Marshall 1999 The study was based on 56 different treatment attempts on 34 patients. Therefore it was a partial cross‐over design as some of the patients would have had more than 1 type of treatment
Martinez 2006 Not randomised
McCann 1996 Cross‐over trial
Milnes 2000 No comparison of groups
Moore 1997 No comparison of groups
Musial 2003 Cross‐over trial
Myers 1977 No comparison of groups
Myers 2004 Cross‐over trial
Nathan 1987 Not randomised
Oei‐Lim 1991 No comparison of groups
 Ages ranging from 23 to 37 years, mental and physical handicapped
Pandey 2010 Cross‐over trial
Pisalchaiyong 2005 Cross‐over trial
Poorman 1990 Not randomised
Primosch 1999 Cross‐over trial
Primosch 2001 Retrospective study
 No comparison of groups
Quarnstrom 1992 Not randomised
Ram 1999 Cross‐over trial
Reinemer 1996 Inappropriate design, partial cross‐over with some subjects having both and others only 1 regimen
Robbins 1967 Inappropriate design, partial cross‐over with some subjects having both and others only 1 regimen
Roberts 1979 Age range 4 to 17 years
 No comparison of groups
Roberts 1982 No comparison of groups
Roberts 1992 Inappropriate design, partial cross‐over with some subjects having both and others only 1 regimen
Robertson 1998 Not randomised (quasi‐randomisation). First patient randomised by toss of a coin, remaining patients alternated
Roelofse 1990 Premedication before general anaesthesia
Roelofse 1993 Premedication before general anaesthesia
Rohlfing 1998 No comparison of groups
Sams 1992 No relevant outcome
Sams 1993b Review
Sanders 1997 No comparison of groups
Shapira 1992 Cross‐over trial
Shapira 1996 Cross‐over trial
Shapira 2004 Cross‐over trial
Sharma 1992 Inappropriate design (partial cross‐over)
Sheroan 2006 Cross‐over trial
Silver 1994 Ages from 3 to 18 years
Songvasin 1990 Cross‐over trial
Subramaniam 2017 Interventions not randomised: "Based on the parent preference of the route of administration, children were then randomly divided into 2 groups"
Sullivan 2001 Cross‐over trial
Tanaka 2000 General anaesthesia
Tobias 1975 Not randomised
Tsinidou 1992 Cross‐over trial
van der Bijl 1991 Adults
Varpio 1991 Not randomised
Veerkamp 1997 Deep sedation
Whitehead 1988 Not randomised (author contacted to confirm)
Wilson 1990 Retrospective study
Wilson 1992 Dose response study measuring physiological outcomes
Wilson 1993 Cross‐over trial
Wilson 2000 Retrospective study
Wilson 2002 Cross‐over trial
Wilson 2003 Cross‐over trial
Wilson 2006 Cross‐over trial
Wilson 2007 Cross‐over trial
Yanase 1996 Cross‐over trial