Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Gordon 1985 | None of the participants met clinical depression criteria according to DSM‐III; the study did not focus on depression. |
Light 1986 | Participants did not meet DSM‐III criteria for depression. |
Moisieva 2018 | The study did not have a randomised design. |
Momtaz 2015 | Results for anxiety and depression were combined, and we received no response from author to our request for raw data. |
Singh 1993 | Depression was not an inclusion criterion, and participants were not screened for depression at the time of recruitment; the study did not focus on depressed COPD patients. |
Strom 1995 | Inclusion criteria only focused on COPD; no criteria specified for depression. |
Subbe 2004 | Depression was not measured by a validated tool. The participants were only asked: "Does feeling low or anxious impair your quality of life?" |
Yohannes 2001 | Not a randomised controlled trial; this was a single‐blinded open study. |
COPD: chronic obstructive pulmonary disease DSM‐III: third edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders