Skip to main content
. 2018 Dec 20;2018(12):CD007964. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007964.pub2

1.32. Analysis.

Comparison 1 COMPARISON 1: CBT+ STANDARD CARE versus STANDARD CARE ALONE, Outcome 32 Mental state: 10d. Specific ‐ depression (average endpoint score various scales, high = poor) (skewed data).

Mental state: 10d. Specific ‐ depression (average endpoint score various scales, high = poor) (skewed data)
Study Interventions Mean SD N
CDS ‐ short term
Barrowclough 2014 CBT + standard care 6.3667 4.3131 48
Barrowclough 2014 Standard care 4.8 4.0 23
CDS ‐ medium term
Barrowclough 2014 CBT + standard care 6.0 4.338 48
Barrowclough 2014 Standard care 6.1 5.3 23
Birchwood 2014 CBT + standard care 8.77 6.04 98
Birchwood 2014 Standard care 8.76 6.24 99
Jackson 2009 CBT + standard care 3.9 3.5 36
Jackson 2009 Standard care 5.9 4.8 30
Tarrier 2014 CBT + standard care 4.0 3.8 17
Tarrier 2014 Standard care 7.2 5.2 18
Trower 2004 CBT + standard care 8.1 7.4 14
Trower 2004 Standard care 12.6 6.7 15
BDI ‐ medium term
Rector 2003 CBT + standard care 11.7 7.9 24
Rector 2003 Standard care 11.8 11.5 18
HAMD ‐ medium term
Granholm 2005 CBT + standard care 11.4 6.3 32
Granholm 2005 Standard care 10.6 6.3 33
MADRS ‐ medium term
Gleeson 2009 CBT + standard care 8.3 9.0 41
Gleeson 2009 Standard care 10.8 11.5 40
BDI ‐ long term
Fowler 2009 CBT + standard care 14.4 12.7 33
Fowler 2009 Standard care 13.6 10.6 38
Garety 2008 CBT + standard care 16.26 13.3075 103
Garety 2008 Standard care 16.4155 13.4444 104
Rector 2003 CBT + standard care 12.0 7.8 21
Rector 2003 Standard care 12.7 11.8 13
CDS ‐ long term
Barrowclough 2014 CBT + standard care 7.0918 5.4566 49
Barrowclough 2014 Standard care 5.9 5.0 21
Birchwood 2014 CBT + standard care 12.44 6.33 98
Birchwood 2014 Standard care 11.75 5.68 99
Jackson 2009 CBT + standard care 3.7 3.9 36
Jackson 2009 Standard care 3.9 3.3 30
HADS ‐ long term
Farhall 2009 CBT + standard care 6.71 4.54 45
Farhall 2009 Standard care 6.57 4.81 47
HAMD ‐ long term
Granholm 2005 CBT + standard care 9.7 5.5 31
Granholm 2005 Standard care 11.3 6.8 33