Skip to main content
. 2018 Dec 20;2018(12):CD007964. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD007964.pub2

3. Data added into generic inverse variance outcome (1.14).

  CBT group Standard care group
Short term Mean SD N Mean SD N
Barrowclough 2014 14.01 3.92 48 14.2 5.2 24
Chen 2015 10.6 3.7 25 11.5 4.1 25
Guo 2015 11.8 3.9 32 13.0 4.4 32
Jia 2005 9.82 2.13 22 12.18 1.84 38
Lewis 2002 13.3 5.06 78 13.67 5.33 60
Li 2013a 12.11 3.08 60 17.76 4.39 58
Naeem 2015 13.1 4.7 53 16.9 5.5 49
Qiu 2014b 13.07 5.3 30 17.28 4.3 29
Wang 2008 9.8 3.4 43 11.2 7.3 41
Wang 2015 10.8 3.51 15 13.33 4.32 15
Total     406     371
             
Medium term Mean SD N Mean SD N
Barrowclough 2001 13.35 4.57 17 16.07 5.54 15
Barrowclough 2010 14.62 4.85 137 14.59 5.35 137
Barrowclough 2014 13.36 3.92 47 14.6 5.1 23
Birchwood 2014 16.06 4.53 98 17.85 5.51 99
Chen 2015 10.2 3.7 25 11.3 3.9 25
Granholm 2005 13.2 5.4 32 12.9 4.6 33
Guo 2015 11.3 4.0 32 11.9 4.6 32
Hu 2013 10.2 4.8 40 10.1 4.9 39
Qiu 2014b 8.17 3.7 30 11.97 4.4 29
Rector 2003 12.0 4.0 24 13.9 6.7 18
Tarrier 2014 12.4 4.9 17 14.9 4.0 18
Wang 2015 9.53 1.68 15 11.8 2.98 15
Total     514     483
             
Long term Mean SD N Mean SD N
Barrowclough 2001 13.87 4.27 17 12.93 4.23 17
Barrowclough 2010 14.07 5.38 129 13.55 5.22 118
Barrowclough 2014 13.62 4.34 50 12.7 5.1 21
Birchwood 2014 16.96 5.32 98 17.3 5.78 99
Farhall 2009 11.78 5.13 45 13.0 4.67 47
Garety 2008 15.12 6.25 111 16.21 6.24 113
Granholm 2005 12.8 6.6 31 14.1 5.0 33
Gumley 2003 8.85 2.09 72 9.88 3.61 72
Guo 2015 10.8 3.8 32 12.8 4.3 32
Lewis 2002 12.45 4.1001 75 15.25 6.44 71
Rector 2003 10.9 3.4 21 11.5 4.7 13
Wang 2015 8.93 1.53 15 11.13 3.66 15
Total     696     651