Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
ACTRN12606000 | Allocation: randomised Participants: not schizophrenia. Study undertaken with persons who were at ultrahigh risk of transition into psychosis. |
Agius 2007 | Allocation: an 'open‐label' cohort study |
Bach 2002 | Allocation: randomised Participants: nonaffective psychotic disorder (schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder). Interventions: the intervention was not a traditional CBT, but about radical acceptance without cognitive or behavioural modifications. |
Barrowclough 2006 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT + treatment‐as‐usual versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Bechdolf 2004 | Allocation: randomised controlled trial Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus psychoeducation |
Bechdolf 2005b | Allocation: an uncontrolled prospective study |
Bradshaw 1996 | Allocation: randomised controlled trial Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus problem‐solving group |
Bradshaw 2000 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Intervention: CBT plus standard care versus standard care Outcome: no usable data, the author did not report the number of participants in each group. |
Byerly 2005 | Allocation: not randomised |
Cai 2014c | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with psychosis (type not stated) |
Cather 2005 | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder, depressed type with residual psychotic symptoms Interventions: CBT versus psychoeducation |
Cella 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive remediation plus treatment‐as‐usual versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Chen 2012 | Allocation: retrospective study |
ChiCTR‐TRC‐14004187 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia, schizoaffective, or delusional disorder according to the criteria of DSM‐V (APA, 2013) Interventions: group CBT versus control intervention (unclear intervention) |
Deng 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT plus entertainment therapy versus entertainment therapy |
Dong 2015 | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus risperidone versus risperidone Outcomes: no usable data and the author did not reported the tools used for measurements |
Drury 1996 | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder, depressed type with residual psychotic symptoms Interventions: CBT versus recreation and support |
Du 2016 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus fluoxetine and other conventional medicine versus fluoxetine and other conventional medicine Outcomes: no usable data and the author did not state the duration of treatment |
Eack 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with substance misuse and schizophrenia |
Farreny 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive remediation (not CBT) versus leisure control |
Favrod 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: meta‐cognitive training plus treatment‐as‐usual versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Feng 2013 | Allocation: not randomised |
Gaudiano 2006 | Allocation: randomised
Participants: people with psychotic disorder Interventions: not CBT, active intervention based on Acceptance and Commitment Therapy |
Granholm 2007 | Allocation: randomised
Participants: people with chronic schizophrenia Interventions: combination of CBT and other active therapies (social skills training plus cognitive remediation/rehabilitation) |
Haddock 1998 | Allocation: randomised
Participants: people with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder (DSM‐IV) Intervention: CBT versus supportive counselling |
Hang 2014 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Hert 2000 | Allocation: randomised
Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: not CBT, active intervention was a relapse prevention program |
Hogarty 1997 | Allocation: randomised
Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: not CBT, active intervention was personal therapy |
Hogarty 2004 | Allocation: randomised
Participants: people with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder Interventions: not CBT, active intervention focused upon cognitive neurorehabilitation and retraining |
Huang 2014 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Ibranhim 2012 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
ISRCTN11889976 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with first episode psychosis |
ISRCTN34966555 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with psychosis with positive symptoms Interventions: CBT delivered through mobile application (app) versus symptoms monitoring app |
ISRCTN47998710 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with psychological difficulties, not schizophrenia |
ISRCTN77762753 | Allocation: randomised Participants: auditory hallucinations (people who heard distress voices) |
Jackson 1998 | Allocation: not randomised |
Jackson 2008 | Allocation: randomised
Participants: people with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder Interventions: CBT versus Befriending (not treatment‐as‐usual) |
Jenner 2004 | Allocation: randomised Participants: PenllteDt (> 10 years), drug‐refractory auditory hallucinations |
Jiang 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus standard care plus psychoeducation versus standard care plus psychoeducation Outcomes: No usable data; the reported outcomes were not predefined for this review (Activity of Daily Living score, Fast Blood Glucose, Post prandial glucose after 2 hours, and HbA1c) |
Johnson 2008 | Allocation: randomised Participants: outpatients with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT versus group supportive therapy |
Kidd 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive remediation plus supported education versus supported education |
Klingberg 2009 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus cognitive remediation |
Kong 2015 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised study |
Kuipers 2004 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with any functional psychosis Interventions: Croydon Outreach and Assertive Support Team versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Lang 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: children with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus standard care versus standard care Outcomes: no usable data, the reported outcomes were not predefined for this review (subscale scores of Wechsler Memory Scale) |
Leclerc 2000 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: coping skill (not CBT) versus control |
Lecomte 2008 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT plus standard care versus standard care versus social skill training |
Li 2013 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT plus antipsychotics versus antipsychotics |
Li 2013b | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT plus antipsychotics versus antipsychotics |
Li 2014b | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus traditional health education (not standard care) |
Li 2015c | Allocation: quasi‐randomised study |
Lin 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia with depression Interventions: CBT citalopram plus antipsychotics versus citalopram plus antipsychotics Outcomes: no usable data, the author did not report data for predefined outcomes |
Lincoln 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT with elements of meta‐cognitive techniques |
Liu 2013 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT and token therapy plus standard care versus standard care |
Liu 2015 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus standard care versus standard care Outcomes: no usable data, the reported outcomes were not predefined for this review |
Lu 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive remediation versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Lu 2014a | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus general supportive psychotherapy |
Lysaker 2009 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia spectrum disorders Interventions: Indianapolis Vocational Intervention Program versus support services |
McLeod 2007 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia who were experiencing auditory hallucinations Interventions: CBT plus standard care versus standard care Outcomes: no usable data, author did not report any predefined outcome data relevant to this review |
Mo 2015 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Morrison 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people at risk of schizophrenia ‐ not people with schizophrenia |
NCT00810355 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) combined with Cognitive Remediation (CR) versus CBT alone versus Support Services (SS) alone |
NCT00960375 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizoaffective disorder or schizophrenia mood disorders, or both, with psychotic features Interventions: behavioural treatment of smoking cessation versus a manualised smoking cessation program |
NCT02105779 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive remediation treatment versus control |
NCT02420015 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Intervention: the two groups received cognitive‐behavioural smoking cessation counselling |
NCT02535923 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with psychosis Intervention: CBT versus 'health and wellness' |
NCT02751632 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with psychosis Intervention: CBT versus 'support and problem‐solving' |
Nordentoff 2005 | Allocation: randomised Participants: first episode of psychosis Interventions: not CBT, assertive community treatment, family involvement, and social skills training |
O'Connor 2007 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with delusional disorders (criteria for schizophrenia had never been met) |
O'Donnell 2003 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: compliance therapy versus supportive counselling |
O'Driscoll 2015 | Allocation: only one arm from an RCT |
Owen 2015 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Penades 2006 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia disorder Interventions: CBT versus cognitive remediation therapy |
Penn 2009 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia spectrum disorders Interventions: group CBT versus Supportive Therapy |
Phillips 2002 | Allocation: not randomised Participants: people at risk of developing psychosis |
Pinto 1999 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia disorder Interventions: CBT combined with social skill training versus supportive therapy |
Qi 2012 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Rector 2005 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Intervention: CBT versus psychoeducation (psychoeducation was not standard care) |
Reeder 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive remediation versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Richmond 2005 | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia with tobacco dependence Interventions: Cognitive Behaviour Therapy (CBT) and nicotine replacement therapy (NRT) versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Sellwood 2000 | Allocation: randomised Participants: schizophrenia Interventions: family‐based intervention versus treatment‐as‐usual |
Sensky 2000 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus befriending |
Shao 2013 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with psychosis, with 59% schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus antipsychotics versus antipsychotics Outcomes: no usable data, the author did not report the treatment duration and length of follow‐up |
Shi 2015 | Allocation: cluster‐randomised Participants: people with chronic schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus medication versus medication Outcomes: no usable data, the author did not report the number of clusters |
Song 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT versus control group (unclear intervention) |
Song 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT plus standard care versus standard care |
Turkington 2008 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus befriending |
Valmaggia 2005 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Intervention: CBT versus supportive counselling |
Wang 2003 | Allocation: randomised Participants: first‐episode schizophrenia Intervention: cognitive therapy plus antipsychotics versus antipsychotics. The cognitive therapy focused on acceptance without cognitive or behavioural modifications. |
Wang 2013 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: antipsychotics plus CBT versus antipsychotics plus health education |
Wang 2013a | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive existence intervention versus community follow‐up |
Wang 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: not CBT but cognitive rehabilitation nursing |
Wei 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive therapy (not CBT) plus antipsychotics versus antipsychotics |
Wu 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: first‐episode paranoid schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus antipsychotics versus antipsychotics Outcomes: no usable data, the author did not report the number of participants in each group |
Wu 2013 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT versus routine nursing psychological care (the nursing psychological care was not standard care and the CBT group did not receive this psychological care) |
Wykes 2005 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT plus standard care versus standard care |
Xie 2013 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Xu 2014 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Yang 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: antipsychotics plus CBT versus antipsychotics plus health education (the health education was not standard care and the CBT group did not receive health education) |
Zeng 2014 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: CBT plus standard care versus standard care Outcomes: no usable data, the author did not report the treatment duration |
Zhang 2005 | Allocation: quasi‐randomised |
Zhao 2012 | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: cognitive insight therapy plus medication versus medication |
Zhou 2015b | Allocation: randomised Participants: people with schizophrenia Interventions: group CBT versus standard care |
CBT = CR = DSM‐IV (or ‐V) = NRT = PenliteD = SS =