Skip to main content
. 2018 Nov 14;2018(11):CD009115. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009115.pub3
Study Reason for exclusion
Aboud 2018 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions); participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Alexander 1991 Trial did not include control data (Types of interventions).
Arnold 2016 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Berninger 2013 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions); trial did not include control data.
Bhide 2013 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Christodoulou 2017 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Dubois 2014 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Foorman 1997 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Foorman 1998 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Gillon 1997 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Gillon 2000 Group allocation did not use randomisation, quasi‐randomisation, or minimisation (Types of studies).
Gillon 2002 Group allocation did not use randomisation, quasi‐randomisation, or minimisation (Types of studies).
Goldstein 2017 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Gorard 2015 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Hatcher 1994 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Hatcher 2006 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Jeffes 2016 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
King 2015 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Lovett 1988 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Lovett 1989 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Lovett 1994 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Lovett 2012 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Merrell 2015 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Messer 2018 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions); participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Metsala 2017 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Munro 2017 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Olson 1992 Review paper (Types of studies)
Olson 1997 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Rashotte 2001 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Savage 2018 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Schaars 2017 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Schlesinger 2017 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Seiler 2018 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Steacy 2016 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Storey 2017 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Torgesen 1997 Reading was not assessed pre‐ and post‐training.
Torgesen 1999a Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Torgesen 2001 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions); trial did not include control data.
Torgesen 2006 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Van Gorp 2017 Participants did not meet this review's criteria for participants (Types of participants).
Vellutino 1986 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Vellutino 1987 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Vellutino 1996 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Wheldall 2017 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Wise 1995 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions); trial did not include control data.
Wise 1997 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Wise 1999 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions).
Wise 2000 Training did not match this review's criteria for phonics training (Types of interventions); trial did not include control data.