DART2 2003.
Methods | Diet and Angina Randomised Trial (DART2) RCT, 2 × 2, (oily fish or capsulesn‐3 EPA + DHA vs nil, also no specific advice, also fruit, vegetables and oats vs no specific advice), 3‐9 years Summary risk of bias: moderate or high |
|
Participants | Men treated for angina N: 1571 intervention, 1543 control (all analysed for events) Control level of risk for CVD: high Men: 100% Mean age in years (SD): 61.1 (NR) intervention, 61.1 (NR) control Age range: unclear Smokers: 25% intervention, 23% control Hypertension: 49% intervention, 47% control Medications taken by at least 50% of those in the control group: not reported Medications taken by 20%‐49%: lipid lowering, beta‐blockers Medications taken by some, but less than 20% of the control group: not reported Location: UK Ethnicity: not reported |
|
Interventions | Type: dietary advice (to eat more oily fish or take fish oil capsules) Comparison: EPA + DHA vs unclear (not total fat, SFA or alcohol, presumably CHO and/or protein but not clear) Intervention: most (1109) advised to eat at least 2 weekly portions of fatty fish OR take MaxEPA capsules, 3/d (0.5 g EPA/d). But 462 participants were sub‐randomised to receive only fish oil capsules, not dietary fish advice. Dose: aimed for 0.5 g/d EPA. Control: none specific sensible eating advice that did not include either of the interventions. Compliance: postal dietary questionnaire suggested dietary EPA intake increased by 2.4 g /week intervention, 0.2 g /week control Dietary achievements Total fat intake, (change from baseline to 6 months): control −8.6 g/d (SD 20.9), intervention −5.2 (g/d SD 21.4) (MD 3.4 g/d) Saturated fat intake, (change from baseline to 6 months): control −3.5 g/d (SD 9.3), intervention −2.8 g/d (SD 9.4), (MD 0.7 g/d) PUFA intake (change from baseline to 6 months): control −1.6 g/d (SD 5.4), intervention −0.1 g/d (SD 5.8) (MD 1.5 g/d) PUFA n‐3 intake (change from baseline to 6 months): EPA, control 0.12 g/week (SD 0.73), intervention 2.65 g/week (SD 1.35) (MD 2.53 g/week) PUFA n‐6 intake: not reported MUFA intake: not reported CHO intake: not reported Protein intake: not reported Trans fat intake: not reported Duration of intervention: 36 to 108 months |
|
Outcomes | Main study outcome: total mortality Dropouts: none for mortality Available outcomes: total and CV deaths, sudden death, stroke, heart failure, cancer deaths Response to contact: yes (data provided) | |
Notes | Some of each group were also advised on high fruit, vegetables and oat diets, and those who received neither fish nor fruit advice received 'non‐specific' dietary advice. All those whose BMI > 30 kg/m2 in both groups received weight reduction advice. Study funding: probably British Heart Foundation, Seven Seas Ltd, Novex Pharma Ltd and the Fish Foundation (these were acknowledged) |
|
Risk of bias | ||
Bias | Authors' judgement | Support for judgement |
Random sequence generation (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Quote: "randomly allocated" |
Allocation concealment (selection bias) | Unclear risk | Pre‐prepared sequentially numbered enveloped opened by dietitian (unclear if envelopes were opaque) |
Blinding of participants and personnel (performance bias) All outcomes | High risk | Dietary advice, so not possible for participants to be blinded to intervention |
Blinding of outcome assessment (detection bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Outcome assessors were not aware of study allocation (Prof Burr stated he did not know assignments) |
Incomplete outcome data (attrition bias) All outcomes | Low risk | Hospital notes and death registers were flagged to catch all outcome data |
Selective reporting (reporting bias) | Unclear risk | No study protocol was found, or trials registry entry |
Attention | High risk | More attention was paid to those given dietary advice |
Compliance | Unclear risk | Postal dietary questionnaire suggested dietary EPA intake increased by 2.4 g/week intervention, 0.2 g/week control |
Other bias | Low risk | None noted |