Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 27;20:23–32. doi: 10.1016/j.jare.2019.04.009

Table 1.

Comparison of common BCA signal amplification methods.

Method Target Year Country Sensitivity Time Principle Advantages Disadvantages References
Chip methods Anthrax 2004 USA 5 × 10−15 mol/L 3–4 h A chip with a surface-fixed capture probe is hybridized with AuNP labelled with the complementary DNA sequence barcode, and silver staining is performed for scanning analysis. Small, portable, fast.
The barcode DNA is highly concentrated on the surface of the chip, and the silver staining method can further amplify the detection signal with high sensitivity.
It is sometimes inconvenient to amplify and detect non-nucleic acid macromolecules. [25]
Human Immunodeficiency Type 1 Capsid (p24) Antigen 2007 USA 100 fg/mL 2–3 h [27]
Hepatitis B Virus Deoxyribonucleic Acid 2010 China 10−15 mol/L 1.5 h [26]
Human IgG 2013 China 1 pg/mL 14 h [24]



Fluorescent labelling Salmonella enterica serovar Enteritidis 2009 USA 1 ng/mL 4 h Barcode DNA is labelled with fluorescent dyes and detected by collecting signals using a fluorescence scanner. Wide application range,
improved sensitivity,
short detection time.
This combination of technologies is not yet mature, and it is necessary to further optimize the experimental steps and conditions to reduce the cost of testing. [30]
Bluetongue virus 2012 China 10−2 fg/mL 3 h [28]
Ricin toxin 2012 China 1 fg/mL 3 h [29]
Multiple DNAs (HCV and HIV) 2017 China 5 × 10−12 mol/L 2 h [31]



Colorimetric methods Cytokines-IL-2 2005 USA 30 × 10−18 mol/L 3 h The sequence is hybridized with the labelled AuNP, and the experimental results are determined according to the change in the colour of the solution. Simple, portable, low cost.
The experimental results can be observed more intuitively through colour changes.
The experimental steps are complicated.
Reproducibility and sensitivity need to be further improved.
[32]
Cytokines-IL-2 2007 USA 10−18 mol/L 3 h [33]
Pesticide triazophos 2017 China 14 ng/L 1 h [34]



Biosensor methods HTLV-I and HTLV-II 2009 China 1.71 × 10−12 mol/L; 1.5 × 10−12 mol/L 1.5 h The AuNP is used as a signal amplifier, and the magnetic probe is used as a splitter.
The signal amplification and silver staining form a complex structure, and other techniques are used for detection.
Variety of sensors, simple operation, good portability, short response time, high sensitivity, low background signal. The detection sensitivity cannot meet the practical requirements for large-scale applications.
Experimental steps are complicated.
[38]
Human platelet antigen 2010 Germany 2 × 10−12 mol/L 150 s [35]
The protective antigen A (pagA) gene of Bacillus anthracis and the insertion element (Iel) gene of Salmonella enteritidis 2010 USA 0.5 ng/mL; 50 pg/mL 1 h [36]
Escherichia coli O157:H7 2018 China 50 CFU/mL 1 h [37]



IPCR Hantaan virus nucleocapsid protein HCV core antigen 2009 China 10 fg/mL 1.5 h Detection of target by antigen-antibody specificity and PCR amplification technology.
Sometimes used in conjunction with fluorescence PCR technology.
High sensitivity and specificity and rapid detection
Can be applied in the diagnosis of cancer, Salmonella, and animal diseases and in food safety testing.
Separate IPCR technology, quantitative uncertainty.
The instrument is expensive, and the results cannot be stored for a long time.
[39]
Polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) 77 2014 China 1.72 pg/L 10 h [40]
PCBs-Aroclor 1248 2015 China 2.55 pg/L 10 h [41]
Staphylococcal enterotoxin B 2019 China 0.269 pg/mL 3 h [42]