Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr 25;6:e00107. doi: 10.1016/j.parepi.2019.e00107

Table 1.

Operational features and performance of molecular methods.

Diagnostic method Operational features Performance Advantage Disadvantage Throughput Optimal setting for field use
Nested PCR
  • Two sets of primers used in successive reactions; therefore, more expense, time and potential contamination than single-step PCR

  • Limit of detection: at least 6 parasites/μL for blood spots

  • More sensitive than single-step PCR for the four main Plasmodium species

  • Hands-on time to result: 3 h; total time: 10 h

  • Simple, it reduces the degree of non-specific binding,

  • The specificity of the PCR reaction is enhanced by reducing the non-specific binding with the help of the two sets of primers

  • Time consuming,

  • Needs more reagents such as extra set of primers, high chance of contamination

High Field applicable
Multiplex PCR
  • Simultaneous, multiplex PCR to detect the presence of multiple Plasmodium species

  • Limit of detection: 0.2–5 parasites/μL

  • Hands-on time to result: 2 h; total time: 4.5 h

  • More information with less sample, cost effective, time saving, high accuracy, less pipetting errors, less contamination.

  • Low amplification efficiency, complex, variability in efficiency in different templates and poor universality

High Field applicable
Quantitative PCR
  • Rapid amplification, simultaneous detection and quantification of target DNA by use of specific fluorophore probes

  • Limit of detection: 0.02 parasites/μL for genus-level identification, 1.22 parasites/μL for P. falciparum detection

  • Hands-on time to result: 1 h; total time: 2.5 h

  • Fast, efficient, and gives a qualitative result

  • It is not cost effective and complex due to simultaneous thermal cycling and fluorescence detection.

High Field applicable
Nucleic acid sequence-based amplification
  • Assay includes a reverse transcriptase step, less inhibition than PCR. Isothermal method. Can be used to quantify gametocytes. Detects all four Plasmodium species, targeting 18S rRNA. Result by fluorescence

  • Limit of detection: 0.01–0.1 para- sites/μL per 50-μl sample

  • Result within 90 min (not including extraction time of about an additional 90 min)

  • A major advantage of NASBA is the production of single stranded RNA amplicons that can be used directly in another round of amplification.

  • It supports the detection of human mRNA sequences without the risk of DNA contamination

  • It helps in better RT-PCR reaction as it offers faster amplification kinetics.

  • Expensive thermocycling equipment is not needed as the reaction occurs isothermally at 41 °C.

High Field applicable
CLIP-PCR
  • Highly sensitive method rRNA of the plasmodium parasite can be released from the blood and then captured onto 96-well plates. Finally, quantified through the number of ligated probes which bounds to it.

  • Capture and ligation probe PCR(CLIP-PCR) which enables to detect the parasite density in blood as low as 0.01 parasites per microliter of blood.

  • CLIP-PCR is highly sensitive, and can detect malaria concentrations as low as 0.01 parasitized cells/microliter of blood

  • Expensive, and complex

High Field applicable
LAMP
  • Boil-and-spin extraction can be used, with amplification by isothermal method. Result determined by turbidity or fluorescence. Sensitivity increases by including mitochondrial targets. Genus-level targets, P. falciparum and P. vivax.

  • Limit of detection: 0.2–2 parasites/μL

  • Results within 30 min with a tube scanner

  • LAMP is cost-effective and requires minimal capital equipment investment

  • Restricted availability of reagents and instruments, no multiplex capability and limitations related with primer design.

  • Does not allow the inclusion of an internal PCR inhibition control (IC)

High Field applicable
HtLAMP
  • A high-throughput LAMP (HtLAMP) platform amplifying mitochondrial targets using a 96-well microtitre plate platform. The HtLAMP assay proved to be a simple method generating a visually-detectable blue and purple colour change that could be objectively confirmed in a spectrophotometer at a wave length of 600 nm.

  • Limit of detection is 2.5 parasites/μL

  • Simple, highly sensitive, and more specific. When compared with PCR, overall HtLAMP-Pg had a sensitivity of 98%

  • LAMP based assays are in general expensive

High Field applicable