Skip to main content
. 2019 May 20;14(5):e0216756. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0216756

Table 3. Performance metrics for 4-s segments.

The the p-values are for the pairwise comparison of the accuracy of the proposed model to each of the other classifiers. The proposed network had a highest accuracy and the results were significant at the 95% confidence level (indicated by a).

Method Public datasets OHCA datasets
Se/Sp BAC/Acc PPV/NPV p-val Se/Sp BAC/Acc PPV/NPV p-val
Proposed network 99.7/98.9 99.3/99.1 96.3/99.9 - 99.2/96.7 98.0/97.5 93.6/99.6 -
Deep learners
 Kiranyaz et al [34] 99.3/98.4 98.9/98.6 94.6/99.8 < .05 97.7/93.8 95.8/95.1 88.4/98.8 < .05
 Zubair et al [56] 95.6/96.2 95.9/96.1 87.5/98.7 < .05 93.9/89.4 91.7/90.9 81.0/96.8 < .05
 Acharya et al [39] 98.4/98.1 98.2/98.2 93.6/99.5 < .05 94.7/91.6 93.2/92.6 84.5/97.3 < .05
Baseline SVM
 SVMall 98.5/98.3 98.4/98.4 94.3/99.6 < .05 91.7/96.0 93.9/94.6 91.7/96.0 < .05
 SVMsel 99.2/98.7 99.0/98.8 95.5/99.8 < .05 93.9/97.1 95.5/96.1 93.9/97.1 < .05