Table 1.
Authors | Type of study | Objective | Results | Policy relevance | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Improving medical care | ||||||
Zachariah et al. (2003)[11] | Cohort | To assess feasibility and effectiveness of voluntary counseling, HIV testing, and cotrimoxazole in patients with TB by use of historical controls in Thyolo, Malawi | Voluntary counseling and testing and adjunctive cotrimoxazole shown to be feasible, safe, and associated with reduced mortality in TB patients under program conditions | Helped in including HIV testing and cotrimoxazole administration in TB patients | ||
Sai Babu et al.[12] | Cross-sectional | Evaluate reasons for noninitiation of t/t in smear positive pulmonary TB reported as ID in 20 districts of Andhra Pradesh, India | Of the total confirmed 685 ID, 51% were untraceable, 22% died before t/t initiation, 13.5% had other reasons (refusal of t/t, chronic case), and no data were available for 8% | Inadequate documentation of referrals, delays in treatment initiation and registration, deficiencies in address documentation were the highlighted areas for program improvement | ||
Assessing feasibility of interventions in specific populations or settings | ||||||
Bedelu et al. (2007)[13] | Descriptive | To weigh ART delivery services through decentralization to primary health care clinics, including nurse-initiated treatment as opposed to physician initiated in Lusikisiki, South Africa | HIV services in Lusikisiki achieved nearly universal coverage within 2 years without compromising quality of care thus proving that a decentralized, model of antiretroviral therapy delivery based on nurses was feasible in rural South Africa | Led to policy change to allow even non-physician clinicians to administer antiretroviral therapy | ||
Tripathy et al. (2010)[14] | Cluster-randomized trial | To assess effect of community mobilization through participatory women’s group in improving birth outcome in tribal clusters of Jharkhand and Orissa, India | NMR was 32% lower in the intervention clusters after adjustments | Importance of involving women groups as an alternative to just having health worker to improve NMR | ||
Advocating policy change | ||||||
Zachariah et al.[15] | Retrospective cohort | To analyze routine treatment outcomes of patients on antiretroviral therapy who did and did not pay for treatment in Kenya | 58% higher risk of loss to follow-up associated with payment for antiretroviral therapy; antiretroviral therapy dilutions by patients who pay for treatment | Policy change occurred and antiretroviral therapy begun to be offered free of charge to all patients in Mbagathi hospital, Kenya | ||
Varkey et al.[16] | Nonequivalent control quasi-experimental | To investigate the feasibility, acceptability, and cost of a new model of maternity care encouraging husband’s participation in their wife’s antenatal and postpartum care in ESI dispensaries in Delhi | Significant improvement was noted in FP knowledge and behavior, and higher client-provider interactions occurred in both men and women in the intervention group. Cost of implementation Rs. 50,000/dispensary/year | On basis of the results, the model was scaled in all ESI dispensaries in Delhi |
TB=Tuberculosis, ID=Initial defaulters, NMR=Neonatal mortality rate, ESI=Employee state insurance, ART=Anti retroviral theraphy, FP=Family planning