Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2020 Jun 1.
Published in final edited form as: J Appl Toxicol. 2019 Jan 28;39(6):888–898. doi: 10.1002/jat.3777

TABLE 2: Average EC50 Values by Flavor Categories.

Compiled EC50 values (% volume of e-liquid) by flavor categories. “Flavorless” e-liquids include Flavorless (Vapor Emporium), Clear (Mister-E-Liquid), and Flavorless (Vape Dudes). “Coffee” e-liquids include Irish Latte (Lotus), G.T.F.O. (Mister-E-Liquid), and Irish Coffee (Vape Dudes). “Fruity” e-liquids include Sweet Melon (Lotus), Watermelon (Mister-E-Liquid), Watermelon Drip (Vape Dudes), Mango Blast (Lotus), XXX Berry (Lotus), Heartbreaker (Mister-E-Liquid), and Possum Sauce (Vape Dudes). “Menthol” e-liquids include Menthol (Lotus), Mister E’s Menthol (Mister-E-Liquid), and ICE ICE (Vape Dudes). “Cinnamon” e-liquids includes Fireball (Lotus), Napalm (Mister-E-Liquid), and Cinn Candy (Vape Dudes). * denotes significant difference when compared to the flavorless category within a cell line (p <0.05). † denotes significant difference when compared to same e-liquid treatment in other cell line (p <0.05).

Cell Line Nicotine Flavorless Fruity Coffee Menthol Cinnamon
MG-63 4.90±0.13 *2.64±0.05 4.09±0.22 *1.92±0.04 *1.40±0.09
+ 4.80±0.21 *2.45±0.06 *3.29±0.29 *1.68±0.05 *1.02±0.20
Saos-2 †3.08±0.06 2.36±0.06 2.60±0.05 *2.14±0.03 †*<0.004
+ †2.99±0.06 2.23±0.10 *2.13±0.14 *1.94±0.09 †*<0.004