Skip to main content
. 2019 Apr;11(4):1170–1181. doi: 10.21037/jtd.2019.04.39

Table 1. Characteristics of included studies.

Study No. of participants Inclusion criteria Interventional algorithm Control group transfusion management Type of study
Ak 2009 224 Elective first-time CABG, with CPB Fully TEG-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Anderson 2006 990 All types of cardiac surgery requiring CPB Fully ROTEM-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RC
Avidan 2004 102 Elective first-time CABG, with CPB Partly TEG-based algorithm, included the Hepcon and PFA-100 platelet function analyser SLTs RCT
Fassl 2013 62 Proximal aortic surgery with induced HCA, requiring CPB Fully ROTEM-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs MCC
Girdauskas 2010 56 High risk aortic surgery including urgent and emergency surgery with HCA, requiring CPB Fully ROTEM-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Görlinger 2011 3,865 All types of cardiac surgery requiring CPB Fully ROTEM-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RC
Karkouti 2016 7,402 All types of cardiac surgery requiring CPB Partly ROTEM-based algorithm SLTs RCT
Kempfert 2011 104 Adult patients with significant postoperative bleeding (>200 mL/h) following standard elective isolated or combined cardiac surgical procedures Fully ROTEM-based algorithm SLTs RCT
Kuiper 2019 355 All types of cardiac surgery requiring CPB Fully ROTEM-based algorithm SLTs PC
Kultufan Turan 2006 40 CABG or valve surgery Fully ROTEM-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Nuttall 2001 92 All types of cardiac surgery requiring CPB, with abnormal microvascular bleeding after CPB Partly TEG-based algorithm, included point-of-care SLTs Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Paniagua 2011 22 Cardiac surgery requiring CPB, with major postoperative bleeding (>300 mL in the first postoperative hour) Fully ROTEM-based algorithm SLTs RCT
Rauter 2007 208 Elective on-pump cardiac surgery Fully ROTEM-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Royston 2001 60 Surgery requiring CPB, with high risk of requiring hemostatic products (Heart transplantation, revascularization bypass, Ross procedure, multiple valve and revascularization surgery) Fully TEG-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Shore-Lesserson 1999 105 High risk cardiac procedure with CPB (Single or multiple valve replacement, combined artery bypass plus valvular procedure, cardiac reoperation, thoracic aortic replacement) Fully TEG-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Spiess 1995 1,079 All types of cardiac surgery requiring CPB Fully TEG-based algorithm Clinical judgement RC
St-Onge 2018 385 Cardiac surgery involving aorta with CPB Fully TEG-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RC
Weber 2012 100 Elective complex cardiothoracic surgery with CPB (combined coronary artery bypass graft and valve surgery, double or triple valve procedures, aortic surgery or redo surgery) Fully ROTEM-based algorithm Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT
Westbrook 2009 69 All types of cardiac procedures with CPB except lung transplantations Partly TEG-based algorithm, included Platelet mapping Clinical judgement and SLTs RCT

CPB, cardiopulmonary bypass; CABG, cardiac artery bypass graft; TEG, thromboelastography; ROTEM, rotational thromboelastometry; SLT, standard laboratory tests; RCT, randomized controlled trial; MCC, matched case-control study; RC, retrospective cohort study; PC, prospective cohort study; HCA, hypothermic circulatory arrest.