Skip to main content
. 2007 Jul 18;2007(3):CD000320. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD000320.pub2

1. Quality assessment.

Trial Allocation sequence generation Allocation concealment Blinding Inclusiona
Amer 1992 Unclear Unclear Unclear Adequate
Amerio 2003 Adequate Adequate Investigators Adequate
Avila‐Romay 1991 Unclear Unclear Unclear Adequate
Bachewar 2009 Adequate Unclear None Inadequate
Biele 2006 Adequate Unclear Investigators Adequate
Brooks 2002 Adequate Unclear Investigators Inadequate
Chouela 1999 Unclear Unclear Described as "double blind"; participants blinded Adequate
Glaziou 1993 Unclear Unclear Outcomes assessor Adequate
Gulati 1978 Unclear Unclear Unclear Adequate
Hansen 1986 Unclear Unclear "Single blind", unclear who was blinded Adequate
Ly 2009 Adequate Unclear None Adequate
Macotela‐Ruiz 1993 Unclear Unclear Participant and outcomes assessor Adequate
Madan 2001 Unclear Unclear Outcomes assessor Inadequate
Maggi 1986 Unclear Unclear Unclear Adequate
Nnoruka 2001 Adequate Unclear Unclear Adequate
Schenone 1986 Unclear Unclear Unclear Adequate
Schultz 1990 Unclear Adequate Outcomes assessor Adequate
Singalavanija 2003 Adequate Unclear Unclear Inadequate
Taplin 1986 Unclear Adequate Investigators Adequate
Taplin 1990 Unclear Adequate Investigators Adequate
Usha 2000 Adequate Adequate None Adequate
Zargari 2006 Unclear Adequate Investigators and participants Adequate

aInclusion of randomized participants in analysis.