Skip to main content
. 2019 May 13;19(9):2206. doi: 10.3390/s19092206

Table 6.

Comparison of traffic prediction approaches.

No. Reference Method Forecast Parameter Input Dataset Dataset Size Data Duration Minimum MAPE
1 [26] LSTM Flow Beijing Traffic Management Bureau 500 observation stations, 26 million records 6 months 6.05
2 [23] Auto- encoders Flow PeMS For all the highways in the system (GBs) 3 months 6.75
3 [27] CNN, LSTM Flow PeMS Includes 60 VDSs 2 months NA
4 [84] DBNs Flow PeMS Roads with top 50 traffic flow values 12 months 9
5 [30] LSTM Speed Self deployed detectors Two sensors, 42387 records 1 month 3.78
6 This paper LSTM Speed PeMS Dataset used in our model 11 years 3.5
7 This paper SVM Speed PeMS Dataset used in our model 11 years 4.6
8 Our Model CNN Speed PeMS Dataset used in our model 11 years 2.59
9 Our Model CNN Flow PeMS Dataset used in our model 11 years 5.96