Skip to main content
. 2019 May 8;19(9):2124. doi: 10.3390/s19092124

Table 1.

Comparison of the speed and accuracy of four ICP algorithms.

Dataset Parameters Algorithms
ICP AA-ICP IMLS-ICP Our ICP
Market Experiment1 (1 m, 0 m, 30°)
Errors (m) 5.808 × 10−3 3.644 × 10−3 1.317 × 10−4 1.556 × 103
Time (s) 125.936 76.455 45.469 12.674
Experiment2 (0.5 m, 0 m, 15°)
Errors (m) 5.806 × 10−3 3.261 × 10−3 3.746 × 105 2.185 × 10−3
Time (s) 56.454 23.113 42.924 13.901
Experiment3 (0.1 m, 0 m, 10°)
Errors (m) 1.755 × 10−3 1.757 × 10−3 3.293 × 104 1.659 × 10−9
Time (s) 54.458 37.008 48.154 22.093
Stgallen Experiment1 (1 m, 0 m, 30°)
Errors (m) 8.662 × 10−3 5.891 × 10−3 1.523 × 104 3.265 × 10−3
Time (s) 239.642 168.634 138.276 21.272
Experiment2 (0.5 m, 0 m, 15°)
Errors (m) 6.039 × 10−3 1.971 × 10−3 6.603 × 105 1.853 × 10−3
Time (s) 158.853 70.818 121.159 23.416
Experiment3 (0.1 m, 0 m, 10°)
Errors (m) 4.159 × 10−3 9.012 × 10−3 4.203 × 105 1.942 × 10−3
Time (s) 156.046 59.321 114.177 20.718
Station Experiment1 (1 m, 0 m, 30°)
Errors (m) 3.096 × 10−2 1.527 × 10−2 2.417 × 105 2.357 × 10−3
Time (s) 57.688 47.728 56.993 12.524
Experiment2 (0.5 m, 0 m, 15°)
Errors (m) 1.368 × 10−2 1.079 × 10−2 2.387 × 104 9.748 × 10−4
Time (s) 51.574 37.425 64.251 12.576
Experiment3 (0.1 m, 0 m, 10°)
Errors (m) 4.911 × 10−3 8.655 × 10−3 9.817 × 105 1.049 × 10−4
Time (s) 54.861 41.817 42.546 12.876