Skip to main content
. 1999 Jan 25;1999(1):CD001440. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD001440

Van Staden 1971.

Methods RCT, Double blind, crossover design, general anaesthetic. Self‐assessed at 1 hour then hourly for 8 hrs. Medication given when pain of moderate to severe intensity.
Participants Gynaecological surgery 
 n = 91 
 Age: adult
Interventions Dextropropoxyphene HCl 65 mg, n = 26 
 Placebo, n = 29
Outcomes PI (4 point scale) standard 
 PR measured as PID (pain intensity difference)
 Dextropropoxyphene was not significantly better than placebo (P not given).
 SPID at 4 hrs: Dextropropoxyphene HCl 65 mg: 1.64 Placebo: 1.57
Notes Remedication allowed after 1 hour if no pain relief. PR scored as zero for all subsequent time points.
 80 patients data were analysed. 11 excluded: 6 violated protocol, 2 vomited, 3 had insufficient pain.
 Authors reported a significant difference from placebo for CNS adverse events (P= 0.05). None serious & no withdrawals. 
 Dextropropoxyphene HCl 65 mg: 19/25 patients reported 27 adverse events.
 Dextropropoxyphene HCl 130 mg:23/25 patients reported 34 adverse events.
 Placebo:10/25 patients reported 12 adverse events.
 QS = 4
Risk of bias
Bias Authors' judgement Support for judgement
Allocation concealment? Low risk A ‐ Adequate

QS = quality score
 PR ‐ pain relief
 PI ‐ pain intensity
 CNS ‐ central nervous system