Skip to main content
. 2019 May 31;14(5):e0217658. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0217658

Table 3. Summary of published research articles identified in the scoping review (1969–2005).

Author; Year/ Country University/ Institution Type of publications Program description Outcome variable/ Measurement instrument Results
Podshadley AG, et al.; 1969/ USA [41]
Heise AL, et al., 1973/ USA [42]
University of Kentucky Original research report “Community Clinical Laboratory” as 6 hours’ course for final year dental students providing comprehensive dental care for rural children with mobile dental units Effect on oral health status, cost-effectiveness, and students’ competencies/Oral examination, cost analysis, questionnaire
  • Improved children’s oral health status

  • Students had positive and new learning experience

  • Cost-effective compared to private practice

Kurtzman C, et al.; 1974 [88] University of California at Los Angeles and University of Southern California Original research report Mobile Dental Project for agriculture workers’ children in rural southern California by dental and dental hygiene students from all classes Effect on oral health services/Descriptive measurement
  • Improved oral health care services

  • Successful met their oral health-related needs

McMillan WB, et al.; 1975 [35] University of Minnesota Original research Summer rural dental externship program for third-year dental students Students’ competencies; dentists’ and students’ satisfaction/Pre-and post-questionnaires
  • Dental students’ positive attitude and preference for rural practice

  • Most aspects for satisfaction were rated above average and excellent by dentists and students

Bentley JM, et al.; 1983/ USA [68] University of Pennsylvania Original research (experimental study) Rural Dental Health Program for rural children randomly assigned to school-based practice group and private practitioners’ group that was further divided into improved dental health program and regular health program. Comparing utilization of services by children over three years/Descriptive measurement
  • Increased dental service utilization by children assigned to school-based practice group offering improved dental health program in contrast to other groups

Feldman CA, et al.; 1988/ USA [69] University of Pennsylvania Follow up study Follow up of the Rural Dental Health Program by Bentley JM, et al.; 1983 [68], evaluated seven years after the funding ended Long-term evaluation after seven years/Health and oral health-related indices
  • Children assigned to community group utilized more professional services and showed more dental knowledge compared to another group with reduced service utilization when project ended

Shreve WB, et al., 1989/ USA [44] University of Florida (contract basis with Lafayette-Suwannee Rural Health Corporation, Inc.) Original research Extramural 2-weeks dental education program for dental students Impact on education, research and services/In-house and external evaluation and surveys
  • Met curricular guidelines and educational objectives of the American Association of Dental Schools

  • Offered good educational experience for dental students

  • Provided comprehensive oral services for rural population and improved their oral health knowledge

Author; Year/ Country University/ Institution Type of publications Program description Outcome variable/ Measurement instrument Results
Burger AD, et al.; 1997/ USA [65] Youngstown State University Original research Dental Disease Prevention and Early Intervention Program to train dental hygiene students and provide essential services to rural population: senior dental hygiene students worked in pairs with supervision of dentist using a mobile dental unit
  • Change in oral health service provision and students’ attitude and experience/Descriptive measurement and survey questionnaire

  • Mostly preventive and simple restorative dental services were provided

  • Students reported positive experience

  • Improved competencies and social sensitization

Pacza T, et al.; 2001/
Australia [59]
University of Western Australia Original research (pilot program) Oral health training program for rural and remote Aboriginal health workers to implement a culturally sensitive preventive oral health care delivery program
  • Attitude of health workers/Questionnaires and focus group discussions

  • Gained pleasant experience and willingness to administer the long-run preventive program

Kaakko T, et al.; 2002/ USA [74] University of Washington Original research (randomized clinical trial) Access to Baby and Child Dentistry (ABCD) program involving Medicaid- enrolled children in rural Stevens County compared with children who had regular benefits
  • Assessment of oral health status, utilization rate and expenditure for Medicaid-enrolled children compared to children with regular benefits/Oral examination and descriptive measurement

  • Significantly improved oral health and utilization rates among ABCD children

  • No cost difference between 2 groups

Richards L, et al.; 2002/ Australia [79] University of Adelaide Clinical report Final year dental students posted in rural public dental service clinics at Whyalla and Port Augusta
  • Cost and benefits analysis/Evaluation of the effect on the waiting list, cost per patient during the course and marginal cost

  • Reduced waiting list and increased number of patients

  • Services provided by students or private providers were more valued, and total cost of the treatment provided by students was found to be greater than public-sector dentists but less than private providers

Mouradian WE, et al.; 2003 [11] University of Washington Original research Interdisciplinary Children’s Oral Health Promotion Project at University affiliated Family Practice Residency Network to train family medicine residents
  • Residents competencies and their ratings for instructors/Questionnaires

  • Improved family medicine residents’ competencies

  • Residents evaluated course quality and instructors’ skills as ‘very good’

Gonsalves WC, et al., 2004/ USA [60] University of Kentucky Original research Physicians’ oral health education for family medicine residents on children’s oral health screening, risk assessment, and counseling
  • Competencies of residents/Pre-test and post-test survey questionnaires

  • Improved knowledge, attitude, self- efficacy, and basic oral health care skills of family medicine residents

Author; Year/ Country University/ Institution Type of publications Program description Outcome variable/ Measurement instrument Results
Woronuk JI, et al.; 2004/ Canada [37] University of Alberta Original research Satellite dental program for third and final year dental students
  • Students’ evaluation by supervising dentists based on four categories: knowledge of preparatory phase, delivery of procedures, patient management and maintenance of infection control standards/Grading scales (1–4 for first three categories and 1 or 2 for fourth category)

  • Most students fulfilled their treatment objectives and were highly motivated with improved clinical competencies

Elkind A, et al.; 2005/ UK [51] University of Manchester Original research (pilot project) Pilot outreach program for final year dental students in restorative dentistry and clinical sessions at the dental hospital
  • Students’ competencies/ Questionnaire

  • Outreach and clinical sessions benefitted each other: Outreach sessions offered treatment planning, emergency care, improved clinical experiences and time management skills whereas clinical sessions offered specialized teaching and improved their clinical competencies

Parker EJ, et al.; 2005/ Australia [82] University of Adelaide Preliminary project report The culturally-sensitive oral health program for the Aboriginal community in Port Augusta—first phase in partnership (with Pika Wiya Health Service, South Australian center for rural and remote health and South Australian Dental service)
  • Community acceptance and change in the demand for services/Descriptive measurement

  • Accepted by the community with immediate demand for services

  • Successful implementation of dental care service by recruiting its own dentist, dental assistant, and Aboriginal health worker