Skip to main content
. 2019 May 31;14(5):e0217658. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0217658

Table 4. Summary of published research articles identified in the scoping review (2006–2010).

Author; Year/ Country University/ Institution Type of publications Program description Outcome variable/ Measurement instrument Results
Bernabe E, et al.; 2006/ Peru [47] Universidad Peruana Cayetano Heredia Original research Dental Public Health Teaching-learning experiences of dental students in low income communities
  • Students’ competencies and experience/ Qualitative interviews

  • Good clinical competencies and enhanced sense of social responsibility among students

Harrison RL, et al.; 2006/ Canada [61] University of British Columbia Original research report Brighter Smiles program trained pediatric residents in a remote First Nations community including brush-ins, fluoride application, oral presentations, and regular visits by pediatric residents
  • Improvement in the oral health of children in a remote First Nations community/Oral examination

  • Improved oral health of children

  • Increased proportion of preventive services and significantly reduced the time needed for extraction of primary teeth by therapists

Author; Year/ Country University/ Institution Type of publications Program description Outcome variable/ Measurement instrument Results
Bazen JJ, et al.; 2007/ Australia [3] University of Western Australia Original research Rural, remote, and Aboriginal pre-graduation placements for dental students under the supervision of dentists
  • Students’ competencies and supervisors’ attitude/ Closed and open-ended questionnaires

  • Positive perception among students and more students preferred rural dental practice

  • Supervising dentist graded students’ clinical competencies and their relationships with patients and local staff as ‘very good’

  • < 1/3rd of the students believed that the 3-week placement was short-term and insufficient to experience and practice rural dentistry

Branson BG, et a.l; 2007/ USA [38] University of Missouri-Kansas City Original research Dental hygiene student rotations to rural and underserved areas
  • Students’ competencies and satisfaction/Qualitative and quantitative (questionnaire) measurements

  • Increased satisfaction among students

  • Improved students’ clinical competencies

Hunter ML, et al.; 2007/ UK [52] Wales College of Medicine Original research (pilot study) Community dental service outreach teaching program for final year dental students for providing pediatric dental care
  • Students’ confidence in comparison to the clinical session at dental school/Pre- and post-questionnaires

  • Students showed higher confidence in providing comprehensive oral care

Lo ECM, et al; 2007/ China [81] University of Hong Kong Original research 3-year outreach dental service program in four primary schools in rural town in southern China (partnered with WHO Collaboration Centre on Primary Health Care)
  • Cost-effectiveness/ Descriptive measurement

  • Cost-effective and affordable

Macnab J, et al.; 2008/ Canada [62] University of British Columbia Original research Same as Harrison RL, et al.; 2006 [61], three years’ evaluation
  • Improvement in oral health and oral health knowledge among school children/Oral examination (oral health indices)

  • Reduced DMFT/dmft score and more caries-free children after three years

  • Dentist noticed improved oral health and knowledge among children

Schoo AM, et al; 2008/ Australia [33] Flinders University and Deaking University Original research (pilot study) Medical, dental, nursing and allied health students were enrolled in the rural placement program
  • Rural recruitment of new graduates/Pre- and post-survey questionnaires

  • Positive association of the rural placement with rural recruitment

  • More urban students began rural practice compared to rural

Shrestha A, et al.; 2008/ India [75] Manipal College of Dental Sciences Original research (cross-sectional survey) Weekly and monthly conduction of rural outreach dental camps
  • Patient satisfaction after one year/Questionnaire

  • High patient satisfaction

Abuzar MA, et al.; 2009/ Australia [25] University of Melbourne Original research Rural dental rotation program for education and training of final year dental students
  • Dental students’ experience/Anonymous questionnaires

  • Students had a positive perception, enriched feeling towards community’s culture and better understanding of community’s dental needs

Author; Year/ Country University/ Institution Type of publications Program description Outcome variable/ Measurement instrument Results
Andersen RM, et a.l; 2009/ USA [55]
Friedman JA, et al.; 2009/ USA [56]
Kuthy RA, et al.; 2009/USA [58]
Thind A, et al.; 2009/ USA [57]
National Pipeline schools (11): Universities of Boston, Howard, Temple, Ohio State, South Carolina, Connecticut Health Center, Washington, West Virginia, University of California at San Francisco, University of Illinois at Chicago, and Meharry Medical College California Pipeline schools (4): Universities of Pacific, Southern California, University of California at Los Angeles, and Loma Linda University Original project USA Dental Pipeline Project– 2001 to 2010, one of the most extensive projects that involved various dental schools aimed to increase the recruitment and retention of students from under-represented minorities (URM) and low-income groups in dental schools
  • Impact on URM enrollment; developing community-based dental education curricula; and extending extramural clinical rotations/ Descriptive measurement

  • Increased enrollment of URM students by 27%, URM students planned to include at least 25% of minority groups as their patients, more diverse dental students’ recruitment, provided context for developing more culturally competent providers

  • URM students noted difficulties such as financial barriers, high education debts, location of dental schools far from their homes, high cost of urban living, perceptions that their dental school was unwelcome, and that schools lacked URM role models

  • Increased extramural facilities and students’ rotations

  • Curricular changes included community-based dental education courses with considerable changes in content, teaching and evaluation methods

Fricton J, et al.; 2009/ USA [84] University of Minnesota Original project (as a chapter in Dental Clinics of North America) University of Minnesota Tele-dentistry Project using real-time video conferencing
  • Acceptance and satisfaction among patients and providers/Questionnaire

  • Increased acceptance and satisfaction among patients and providers

Skinner JC, et al; 2009/ Australia [54] Charles Sturt University Original research report Charles Sturt University Dentistry program for rural students to study and practice dentistry in rural areas
  • Rural recruitment and retention of graduates/ Descriptive measurement

  • The project estimated up to 60% retention of the first cohort of 2014 graduates in the rural areas

Arevalo O, et al.; 2010/ USA [91] University of Kentucky Original research (cost analysis) Dental Outreach Programs Kentucky: four mobile dental clinics for elementary school children and Head Start children in several rural counties
  • Financial feasibility of mobile dental units/ Financial analysis

  • Financially, mobile units were good option for accessing rural underserved population

  • Ongoing program

  • Conducted many successful outreach activities with improved oral health of children

McFarland KK, et al.; 2010/ USA [49] University of Nebraska Original research (retrospective study) Analysis of dental students’ attitudes from 1989 to 2008 about rural practice
  • Pattern of dental students working in rural practice after graduation/ Descriptive measurement

  • More non-residents than residents and more women than men, who remained in the state after graduation, were located to practices in rural communities