Study | Reason for exclusion |
---|---|
Axelson 2011 | Unclear diagnostic criteria, unclear participant characteristics, unclear if open or blinded, unclear randomisation |
Bowden 2008 | Open‐label study |
Brockington 1978 | Nonstandard diagnostic process. Not clearly participants with bipolar disorder. Unclear if randomised or not |
Calabrese 2002 | Mixture of depressed, euthymic and manic participants. No subgroup of manic participants presented |
Calabrese 2005 | Complex study. Recruited participants who were either euthymic or manic. Those who were manic had an open‐label stabilisation prior to randomisation. Then were randomised for maintenance therapy. Not an acute mania study. |
Chou 2009 | Lithium in both arms of the study |
Christie 1989 | Open‐label study |
El‐Mallakh 2012 | Maintenance study ‐ participants not acutely manic |
Giannini 1984 | Not a RCT |
Giannini 1986 | Clonidine is not one of the agreed comparators |
Goodwin 1979 | Lithium vs 'neuroleptics'. No individual drug data |
Johnson 1971 | No standard diagnostic criteria/method of diagnosis |
Kwon 2001 | Mixture of depressed and manic participants |
NCT00314184 | Maintenance study ‐ participants not acutely manic |
NCT01166425 | Study protocol. Appears to have either not occurred or was replaced by the study which is Findling 2015 |
Nieto 2014 | Naturalistic study, non‐randomised |
Okuma 1990 | Unclear diagnostic criteria |
Pavuluri 2004 | Open‐label study and group with Lithium only n = 4 (valproate vs placebo vs placebo + lithium) |
Pokorny 1974 | Mixture of participants ‐ unipolar and bipolar disorders in all mood states. Unclear diagnostic criteria |
Swann 2001 | Randomisation occurred after mood stabilisation ‐ so this was a maintenance study |
Takahashi 1975 | Unclear diagnostic criteria. Unblinded. Non validated outcome measures |
RCT: randomised controlled trial