Skip to main content
. 2013 Dec 20;2013(12):CD010884. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010884

2. RCTs of exercise interventions screened out of resistance training review.

Study (primary and secondary citations)* Number of groups Interventions
Alentorn‐Geli 2008 3 MX, Comp (Vib+MX), Control
Altan 2004 2 AQ‐MX, Bal 
Altan 2009 2 MX, Relax+FX 
Arcos‐Carmona 2011 2 AQ+LD MX, Control (placebo magnet therapy) 
Assis 2006 2 AE, AQ‐AE 
Astin 2003 2 Mindfulness Meditation; Control
Baptista 2012 2 Dance; Wait List Control
Bojner Horwitz 2006 2 Dance/Movement; Control
Bressan 2008 2 2 groups: FX, AE 
Buckelew 1998 4 4 groups: Biof+Relax, MX, Comp (Biof+Relax+MX), Control (Educ/Attention)
Burckhardt 1994 3 Comp (ED+MX), ED, Control (Delayed treatment)
Calandre 2009 2 FX, AiChi 
Carson 2010; Carson 2012 2 COMP (Yoga, meditation, breathing exercises, ED), Control (Wait List) 
Cedraschi 2004 2 Comp (AQ+Land AE, Relax, ED), Control 
Demir‐Gocmen 2013 2 MX (FX+Coord)/HPrg (FX)
Da Costa 2005 2 AQ+LD MX, Control (TAU) 
De Andrade 2008 2 AQ‐(AE), AQ‐(AE) SPA 
de Melo Vitorino 2006 2 AQ‐MX, LD‐MX 
Etnier 2009 2 MX, Control ‐ Delayed Entry 
Evcik 2008 2 AQ‐MX, MX 
Field 2003 2 COMP (Self Massage+FX), Relax 
Fontaine 2007 2 LPA (likely mostly aerobic), ED  
Fontaine 2010; Fontaine 2011 2 LPA (likely mostly aerobic), ED 
Garcia‐Martinez 2012 2 MX (AE+ST+FX); Control
Genc 2002 2 MX, COMP (Non ex intervention, Remedial Ex, Relax, Mobil) 
Gowans 1999 2 Comp (AQ‐AE+ED), Control (Wait List)
Gowans 2001; Gowans 2002 2 AQ‐AE+LD AE, Control (TAU) 
Gusi 2010; Olivares 2011 2 VIB, Control (TAU) 
Gusi 2006; Tomas‐Carus 2007a; Tomas‐Carus 2007b; Tomas‐Carus 2007 2 AQ‐MX , Control 
Hammond 2006 2 COMP (Educ+SMP+MX), Relax
Hecker 2011 2 AQ MX, MX 
Hooten 2012 2 COMP (MX+pain prg), COMP (MX+pain prg)
Hunt 2000 2 MX, Control 
Ide 2008 2 AQ‐COMP (AE+Relax), Control (Supervised ˜PA Recreational Activities)  
Isomeri 1993 3 AE, ST+Meds, AE+Meds
Jentoft 2001 2 AQ‐MX, MX 
Jones 2007; Jones 2008 4 Comp Meds+MX, Meds+Placebo (Diet Recall), Placebo Med+MX, Control: Placebo Med+Placebo Diet Recall
Jones 2012 2 Tai Chi; Educ
Joshi 2009 2 MX; Med
Keel 1998 2 Comp (MX, ED, Relax), Relax 
King 2002 4 AE (AQ ± LD), ED, Comp (AE AQ ± LD+ED), Control
Lemstra 2005 2 Comp (MX+Educ+SMP+Massage), Control 
Liu 2012 2 Qi Gong/sham QiGong
Lopez‐Rodriguez 2012 2 AQ Biodance
Lynch 2012 2 Qi Gong/Wait List Control
Mannerkorpi 2000 2 AQ‐MX, Edu 
Mannerkorpi 2009 2 COMP AQ‐MX+ED, ED 
Mannerkorpi 2010 2 AE (moderate intensity), AE (low intensity) 
Martin 1996 2 MX, Relax
Martin‐Nogueras 2012 2 MX (FX+FX+Relax)/Control
Matsutani 2007 2 COMP (Educ+Laser+FX), COMP (Educ+FX) 
Matsutani 2012 2 AE, FX
McCain 1988 2 AE, FX 
Mengshoel 1992; Mengshoel 1993 2 AE‐Dance, Control 
Munguia‐Izquierdo 2007; Munguia‐Izquierdo 2008 3 AQ‐MX, Control (fibromyalgia), Control (Healthy)
Nichols 1994 2 AE, Control 
Norregaard 1997 2 AE, MX, Thermotherapy
Ramsay 2000 2 AE, AE (CV) 
Richards 2002 2 AE, Comp Relax+FX 
Rivera Redondo 2004 2 AQ+LD MX, CBT 
Rooks 2007 4 MX1, MX2, FSHC, FSHC+MX
Sanudo 2010 2 MX, Comp (MX+Vib) 
Sanudo 2010a 3 AE, MX, Control (TAU)
Sanudo 2010c 2 AE, Control 
Sanudo 2011 2 MX, Control (TAU, AAU) 
Sanudo 2012 2 MX (Vib+AE+ST+FX); MX (AE+ST+FX)
Schachter 2003 3 AE ‐ long bout, AE ‐ short bout, Control (TAU)
Schmidt 2011 3 Comp (Meditation Yoga), Comp (Relax+FX), Control (Wait List)
Sencan 2004 3 AE, Meds, Control
Tomas‐Carus 2008; Tomas‐Carus 2007c; Gusi 2008 2 AQ‐MX, Control 
Valencia 2009 2 COMP (Relax+MX) , FX (Meziere Method) 
Valim 2003 2 AE, FX 
Valkeinen 2008 2 MX, C (AAU) 
van Koulil 2010 2 Comp CBT1 + AQ/LD MX, Comp CBT2 + AQ/LD MX 
vanSanten 2002a 3 MX, Biofeedback, Control
vanSanten 2002 2 MX (self selected intensity), AE (moderate to vigorous intensity)
Verstappen 1997 2 MX, Control
Wang 2010 2 Tai Chi, Comp (FX + ED)
Wigers 1996 3 AE, SMT, Control (TAU)
Yuruk 2008 2 MX1, MX2

AAU: activity as usual; AE: aerobics; AQ: aquatics; Biof: biofeedback; spa: balneotherapy; CBT: cognitive behavior therapy; Comp: composite; ED: education; FX: flexibility; LD: land; LPA: leisure time physical activity; LifePA: lifestyle physical activity; Meds: medication; Multi: multidisciplinary program; ˜: not, or non; MX: mixed exercise; Relax: relaxation; SMP: self management program; ST: strength; SM: stress management; Spa: thelassotherapy; TAU: treatment as usual; TENS: transcutaneous electrical stimulation; Vib: whole body vibration.

* Seven trials had more than one publication. In total, there were 73 trials with 14 additional publications.