Table 1. Studies of Exposure to 13 Reasons Why.
Source | Sample Size | Sample Source | Study Design | Dependent Variable | Negative Outcome | Positive Outcome |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cooper et al,8 2018 | 775 | 2002-2017 Suicidal pediatric admissions; Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, United States | Ecological study of suicide attempt admissions in children’s hospital before and after the release of the show | Suicide-oriented admissions, ED | Admissions increased after watching the show | None |
Rosa et al,9 2019 | 7004 | 84% Female, Facebook; Brazil | Cross-sectional study among exposed adolescents; retrospective self-reports on changes in mood | Changes in mood | 23.7% Reported worsening in mood after watching the show | 32.1% Reported improvement in mood after watching the show |
Feuer and Havens,10 2017 | NA | Data from 14 sites on a hospital-based listserv; United States | Survey among pediatric emergency services on increases in admission volume before and after the release of the show | Suicide attempt or gesture related to the show | 40% Of sites reported at least 1 case with imitation gestures or attempts within 30 d of watching the show | None |
Hong et al,11 2019 | 87 | Suicidal patients, ED; 49% exposed to the show; United States | Cross-sectional study among parent-youth dyads during ED visit; retrospective self-reports on suicide risk and identification with main character of the show | Self-reported increase in suicide risk | 51% Of those exposed reported increase in SR; persons who identified with main female character and persons with history of suicidality were at even higher SR | None |
Zimerman et al,12 2018 | 21 062 | Facebook sample; persons who liked the show, predominately Brazilians (80.1%) and Americans (19.9%) | Surveys on bullying, depression, and SI among adolescents before and after exposure to the show | Self-reported SI, depression, and bullying behavior before and after watching the show | Of individuals with preexisting SI, 16.5% reported more SI after watching the show | Of individuals with preexisting SI, 59.2% reported less SI after watching the show; of adolescents who had engaged in bullying, 90.1% engaged in less bullying after watching the show |
Lauricella et al,14 2018 | 1880 Parents; 1722 adolescents; 1798 young adults | Survey in 4 world regions | Cross-sectional study among adolescents, young adults, and parents; retrospective self-reports on experiences with and attitudes toward the show | Experiences with and attitudes toward the show | No suicide-related outcomes reported | Several positive outcomes, including 63%-79% of adolescents who reported watching the show was positive for them |
Abbreviations: ED, emergency department; NA, not applicable; SI, suicidal ideation; SR, suicide risk.