Skip to main content
. 2019 Jun 10;14(6):e0217905. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0217905

Table 1. Online sources for extracting monthly civilian casualties, monthly attacks on healthcare facilities, and monthly Syrian refugee counts.

Online Sources Data Type Duration of Documentation Description of Documentation Verification Methodology
Violations Documentation Center (VDC)[39] Civilian Casualties Mar. 2011 to present 1. Gather initial information from hospital registries, morgues, relatives or media sources
2. Confirm initial report with videos or photographs
3. Key information missing is investigated until published44
Three-stage verification process: initial reports, video/photo evidence, investigation until confirmed
Physicians for Human Rights (PHR)[38] Attacks on Healthcare Facilities* Mar. 2011 onwards Uses social media, publications and field sources to identify attacks before publishing attacks on healthcare facilities and personnel on their online platform Verification by at least two independent sources before publication of confirmed attacks
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)[45] Registered Syrian Refugees Mar. 2011 onwards Government agencies, UNHCR field offices and NGOs contribute to UNHCR’s online database for cumulative refugee counts Verification by three independent sources

*Attacks on healthcare facilities are defined as a violent assault (e.g. bombing, shelling, artillery, car bombs, shooting, arson, or attack by armed personnel) on a hospital, clinic, medical center, pharmacy, dispensary or field hospital.[21]