Table 1. Online sources for extracting monthly civilian casualties, monthly attacks on healthcare facilities, and monthly Syrian refugee counts.
Online Sources | Data Type | Duration of Documentation | Description of Documentation | Verification Methodology |
---|---|---|---|---|
Violations Documentation Center (VDC)[39] | Civilian Casualties | Mar. 2011 to present | 1. Gather initial information from hospital registries, morgues, relatives or media sources 2. Confirm initial report with videos or photographs 3. Key information missing is investigated until published44 |
Three-stage verification process: initial reports, video/photo evidence, investigation until confirmed |
Physicians for Human Rights (PHR)[38] | Attacks on Healthcare Facilities* | Mar. 2011 onwards | Uses social media, publications and field sources to identify attacks before publishing attacks on healthcare facilities and personnel on their online platform | Verification by at least two independent sources before publication of confirmed attacks |
United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)[45] | Registered Syrian Refugees | Mar. 2011 onwards | Government agencies, UNHCR field offices and NGOs contribute to UNHCR’s online database for cumulative refugee counts | Verification by three independent sources |
*Attacks on healthcare facilities are defined as a violent assault (e.g. bombing, shelling, artillery, car bombs, shooting, arson, or attack by armed personnel) on a hospital, clinic, medical center, pharmacy, dispensary or field hospital.[21]