Table 5.
Meditation included studies
Project identifier | Design | Sample size | Intervention/duration | Outcome/time |
---|---|---|---|---|
[43] USA | one group pretest-posttest design | 175 MD | 10 meditation i.s. + mantra’s repetition daily /10 weeks |
Post-int ↓ distress |
[44] USA |
one group pretest-posttest pilot design |
5 MBCT | 8 mindfulness-based stress reduction and cognitive therapy g.s and 1 mindfulness-based stress reduction and cognitive therapy i.s. + daily practice /8 weeks |
Post-int & 4 month ↓ depressive symptoms ↑ dispositional mindfulness ↑ QoL |
[45, 115, 116] USA |
one group pretest-posttest pilot design + QA |
adolescents 59 (11HIV+) MBSR |
9 body scan, mindfulness meditation, yoga g.s of 2 h + daily practice /8 weeks |
Post-int Feasible and acceptable ↓ symptoms (hostility and discomfort) |
[46] USA |
one group pretest-posttest pilot design + QA |
11 MCPA | 5 noticing positive events, capitalizing, gratitude, mindfulness, positive reappraisal, personal strengths, attainable goals, kindness, i.s. + daily home practice /6 weeks |
Post-int Feasible and acceptable ↑ positive affect ↓ negative affect |
[47] USA |
one group pretest-posttest pilot design + QA |
9 MABT | 8 massage, interceptive training, mindful body awareness i.s. of 1 h30 + home practice /8 weeks |
Post-int Feasible and acceptable |
[48] Conference abstract UK |
one group pretest-posttest pilot design + QA |
12 CFT | 8 attention, emotional regulation, mindfulness practice g.s. of 2 h /8 weeks |
Post-int Feasible and acceptable |
[49] USA | untreated control group with pretest and posttest design | 24 MBSR |
8 body scan, mindfulness meditation, hatha yoga g.s. of 2 h30 + daily home practice /8 weeks |
Post-int & 5 months ↓ mood disturbance ↓ stress ↑ NK cell number and activity |
10 CG | usual care | |||
[50] Thailand | action research: mixed method | 16 PSM | 8 mindfulness meditation, emotional reflective techniques s. + daily home practice /8 weeks |
Post-int ↓ suffering |
[51, 117] USA | untreated control group with pretest and posttest design + QA | 21 3S+ | 12 cognitive-behavioral spirituality focused psychotherapy, mindfulness training i.s. + daily mindfulness home practice /12 weeks |
Post-int ↓ impulsivity ↑ spirituality |
17 CG | usual care | |||
[52] USA | RCT | 10 ST | 4 support group g.s. of 1 h30 /4 weeks | |
10 CBST | 4 Benson’s relaxation exercises, cognitive-behavioral stress training g.s. of 1 h30 + twice daily home practice/ 4 weeks | |||
10 WL | wait-list | |||
[53] USA | RCT | 13 MT | 1 meditation g.s. of 90 min + daily meditation home practice /4 weeks |
Post-int & 2 months To MT + MSSG: ↑ QoL |
13 MSSG | 20 massage i.s. of 30 min /4 weeks | |||
16 MT + MSSG | 1 meditation g.s of 90 min + daily meditation home practice + and 20 massage i.s of 30 min /4 weeks | |||
16 Control | usual care | |||
[54, 118] USA | RCT | 46 MT | 6 mantra’s repetition g.s. of 90 min and group discussion + daily practice /10 weeks |
Post-int & 22 weeks ↓ anger ↑ spiritual wellbeing |
47 ACG | 6 videotapes on HIV-topics g.s. of 90 min and group discussion /10 weeks | |||
[55, 119] USA | RCT | 33 MBSR | 8 body scan, mindfulness meditation, yoga g.s. of 2 h + a day long retreat (6 h) + daily practice /10 weeks |
Post-int = CD4 counts |
15 CG | 1 day MBSR information | |||
[56, 120] Iran | RCT | 120 MBSR | 8 body scan, mindfulness meditation, yoga g.s. of 2 h + 1 day of retreat (6 h) + daily practice /8 weeks |
Post-int & 12 months ↓ physical symptoms |
125 ESC | 2 HIV education g.s of 2 h | |||
[57] USA | RCT | 40 MBSR | 8 body scan, mindfulness meditation, yoga g.s. of 2 h30 + 1 day of retreat (6 h) + daily practice /8 weeks |
Post-int ↓ ARV side effects |
36 CG | wait-list | |||
[58] Canada | RCT | 78 MBSR | 8 body scan, mindfulness meditation, yoga g.s. of 3 h + 1 day of retreat (6 h) + daily practice /8 weeks |
Post-int & 6 months ↓ avoidance ↑ positive affect ↑ mindfulness |
39 CG | usual care | |||
[21] USA | pilot RCT | 11 TM | 14 transcendental meditation s. + daily home practice /24 weeks |
Post-int Feasible and acceptable ↑ HRQoL |
11 HE | 14 healthy eating education s. |
MD meditation, i.s. individual sessions, Post-int post intervention, MBCT mindfulness-based cognitive therapy, g.s group sessions, QoL quality of life, QA qualitative approach, MBSR mindfulness-based stress reduction program, RCT randomized controlled trial, QE qualitative evaluation, MCPA multiple-component positive affect, MABT mindful awareness in body-oriented therapy, CFT compassion-focused therapy, 3-S+ spiritual self-schema therapy, PSM palliative-suffering model, TM transcendental meditation, HE healthy eating education, HRQoL health related quality of life, ST support training, SIT stress inoculation training, WL wait list, MT mantra, MSSG massage, MT + MSSG mantra + massage, ACG attention control group, CG control group, ESC education and support condition