Table 4.
Comparison to previous literature
| Previous study | Current study | ||
| Study population | Findings | Findings | |
| Fuller et al, 20094 | TARN eligible patients at TARN submitting hospitals (approx. 50% England) between 2003 and 2009. | From the period 2004 onwards as the proportion of patients with TBI transferred and managed in neuroscience centres increased and the risk adjusted mortality rate for TBI fell. | Complete national data for all hospital in England. A reversal in trend in the mortality rate in the 16–64 age group when the second NICE guideline recommending management of patients with severe injuries in specialist centres was introduced. |
| Marlow et al 24 | Patients aged <16 with ICD10 codes indicating head injury admitted to hospitals in England between 2000 and 2011. | Assessed the annual rate of inpatient deaths (all-cause mortality) for patients admitted with ICD10 codes indicating head injury. Found the death rate fell across the time period, but there was only a statistically significant reduction in the death rate after the 2007 NICE head injury guideline. |
The inpatient TBI mortality rate (as indicated by coding of death certificates) for patients aged <16 fell from 1998 to 2017 and was unaffected by the introduction of the NICE guidelines. |
| The Trauma Audit and Research network report: major trauma in older people25 | TARN eligible patients at TARN submitting hospitals between 2005 and 2014 (all hospitals in England by 2014) | A large increase in major trauma, including TBI, in patients 65+, disproportionate to UK population demographic changes. Hypothesised due to increased case ascertainment due to more liberal CT imaging. |
We found a large increase in the admission rate for TBI in those 65+ from 10 per 100 000 population to 30 per 100 000 population between 2002 and the point the third NICE guideline was introduced in 2014. |